IF I WERE A WHALE by Shelley Gill

IF I WERE A WHALE

by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 1 - 3
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Rhyming text introduces youngsters to a smattering of whales.

Unfortunately, it’s not particularly good rhyme, nor are the whales introduced with enough context to make the information meaningful to a toddler audience. “I might be a gray whale with barnacles on my chin / Or a sleek, slender fin whale. Think how fast I’d swim.” To these bloodless rhymes are paired equally anemic watercolor illustrations. The nature of whale coloration and their marine habitat combine for spreads that are dominated by grays and pale blues, the lack of contrast making for a singularly uncompelling visual experience. Weeds and other sea life add some mild pops of color, but they are so watery they don’t make much of an impression. In addition to the aforementioned gray and fin whales, Gill packs an impressive number of whale species in: minke, beluga, pilot, blue, beaked, orca, humpback, and—“Narwhals have tusks. Tusks might come in handy. / Right whales sail with their tails. Wouldn’t that be dandy?” Ouch.

The book’s heart is in the right place, but its execution serves neither subject nor audience even adequately. (Board book. 1-3)

Pub Date: Feb. 21st, 2017
ISBN: 978-1-63217-104-7
Page count: 20pp
Publisher: Little Bigfoot/Sasquatch
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2017




MORE BY SHELLEY GILL

ChildrenGABE by Shelley Gill
by Shelley Gill
ChildrenALASKA'S DOG HEROES by Shelley Gill
by Shelley Gill
ChildrenPRICKLY ROSE by Shelley Gill
by Shelley Gill

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenLOOK! FISH! by Stephanie Calmenson
by Stephanie Calmenson
ChildrenBEACH BABY by Laurie Elmquist
by Laurie Elmquist
ChildrenSLEEP SAFE, LITTLE WHALE by Miriam Schlein
by Miriam Schlein