EXCELLENT ED by Stacy McAnulty
Kirkus Star

EXCELLENT ED

Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Ed, the Ellis family dog, has many talents, but none of them matches the excellence of the five Ellis children’s—or so he thinks.

Ed longs for a place at the family table, in the van, and on the couch, if only he can think of something that he excels at. But from soccer and ballet to math and baking, Elaine, Edith, Ernie, and twins Emily and Elmer outdo Ed at things that seem the most important (and delightfully counter to gender-stereotypical fashion). Endpapers show Ed twirling and rolling across the title page and into the story, where he’s maneuvered himself right out of the striped sweater he’s been dressed in. He sits wagging his tail at the feet of all five of the Ellis kids, their affection for one another and for their dog obvious. There is a lot of humor in the illustrations and wordplay that children will delight in. Ed imagines that he might be best at “breaking stuff,” till Elaine comes along boasting of a broken record, for instance. A frustrated Ed finally feels noticed for the talents that only he has: cleaning the floor when food is spilled and giving a warm doggy welcome when the family comes home. Rounded, loose lines and vivid splashes of color in acrylics, watercolor, crayon, and grease pencil make for a cheery depiction of life in a middle-class African-American household.

A warm, welcome reminder that everyone is excellent at something. (Picture book. 3-6)

Pub Date: May 17th, 2016
ISBN: 978-0-553-51023-2
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1st, 2016




MORE BY STACY MCANULTY

ChildrenMR. FUZZBUSTER KNOWS HE'S THE FAVORITE by Stacy McAnulty
by Stacy McAnulty
ChildrenIT'S NOT A DINOSAUR! by Stacy McAnulty
by Stacy McAnulty
ChildrenBEAUTIFUL by Stacy McAnulty
by Stacy McAnulty

MORE BY JULIA SARCONE-ROACH

ChildrenTHE BEAR ATE YOUR SANDWICH by Julia Sarcone-Roach
by Julia Sarcone-Roach
ChildrenINCREDIBLE INVENTIONS by Lee Bennett Hopkins
by Lee Bennett Hopkins

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenMARTHA CALLING by Susan Meddaugh
by Susan Meddaugh
ChildrenOFFICER BUCKLE AND GLORIA by Peggy Rathmann
by Peggy Rathmann
ChildrenWHISTLE FOR WILLIE by Ezra Jack Keats
by Ezra Jack Keats