MAKING OUR DEMOCRACY WORK by Stephen Breyer

MAKING OUR DEMOCRACY WORK

A Judge's View

KIRKUS REVIEW

For the general reader, a sitting Justice explains how the Supreme Court won the public trust and what it must do to keep it.

Employing a succession of cases from Marbury v. Madison to Bush v. Gore, Breyer (Active Liberty: Interpreting Our Democratic Constitution, 2005) offers a short, highly accessible course on the evolution of judicial review, the doctrine permitting the Court to invalidate laws conflicting with the Constitution. Although history and tradition explain how the Court’s decisions and interpretations have earned deference from public officials and acceptance from the citizenry, preserving that hard-won, critical role in our democracy, the author insists, requires the Court to issue decisions that ensure the Constitution works in practice. Rejecting originalism, political or subjective preferences, he argues for a pragmatic interpretation of the Constitution that looks first to the purposes and consequences of the law and relies on strength of reasoning for persuasion. Applying an 18th-century document to the unanticipated controversies of the modern nation or divining the meaning of frequently incomplete or silent statutes is rarely simple. The merits of any single case aside, the Court must also take into account a variety of legal doctrines, properly respect the expertise and prerogatives of the other governmental branches and avoid insult to state and inferior U.S. courts in our federal system, all in the service of forging decisions acceptable to the country. In a passage on the Court’s special province, protecting individual rights, Breyer takes us through a judge’s thinking—how he identifies the enduring value in a constitutional provision and applies it to particular facts. The author concludes with a comparison of the infamous Korematsu decision approving the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II with the four recent Guantánamo cases, in which the Court adopted a more workable approach, even during a time of serious national threat, to protect constitutional values.

Speaking out without talking down, Breyer renders a signal service to his fellow citizens.

Pub Date: Sept. 14th, 2010
ISBN: 978-0-307-26991-1
Page count: 288pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2010




THE BEST POLITICAL BOOKS OF 2010:

Nonfiction HERDING DONKEYS by Ari Berman
by Ari Berman
Nonfiction MAKING OUR DEMOCRACY WORK by Stephen Breyer
by Stephen Breyer
Nonfiction MY NUCLEAR FAMILY by Christopher Brownfield
by Christopher Brownfield
Nonfiction CULTURES OF WAR by John W. Dower
by John W. Dower

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionTHE NINE by Jeffrey Toobin
by Jeffrey Toobin
NonfictionTHE SUPREME COURT by Brian Lamb
by Brian Lamb
NonfictionAMERICAN ORIGINAL by Joan Biskupic
by Joan Biskupic