REFLECTIONS OF AN AFFIRMATIVE ACTION BABY by Stephen L. Carter

REFLECTIONS OF AN AFFIRMATIVE ACTION BABY

KIRKUS REVIEW

 Affirmative-action programs have ``run their course'' and, according to this overworked, self-referential diatribe from Carter (Yale/Law), that's all to the good. A Stanford graduate, Carter entered Yale in 1977. ``I got into a top law school,'' he offers, ``because I am black--so what?'' He argues here that all should be based on merit and that affirmative action--what he decries as ``racial preference''- -further ghettoizes blacks by not allowing them to compete against ``the best.'' The ``taint''--the idea that success was achieved solely because of race rather then merit--haunts all black professionals, says Carter, lamenting also the ``biology implies ideology'' presupposition that there is only one correct black viewpoint, that a minority member who expresses a view that a white could hold is ``not a bona fide representative of [his] people.'' Carter empathizes with ``dissenters'' such as author- historian Shelby Steele and controversial sociologist William Julius Wilson, intellectuals who have gone against the grain by not speaking ``for'' the black race and who have been criticized as ``neoconservative'' and branded traitors. Affirmative action, claims Carter, has lowered general standards to meet racial quotas rather than spurred minorities on to being ``too good to ignore.'' It's been ``a convenience,'' a means of avoiding more costly, difficult solutions. He doesn't go into detail, but he offers the Head Start program and refers hazily to the ``policy initiatives'' of the War on Poverty as possible answers. While his analysis has undeniable merit, Carter's call for a reemphasis on ``societal commitment'' and ``a loving solidarity'' as the means to gaining equity and achievement for black Americans seems to overlook the harsh historical reality and pervasive attitudes that made affirmative action a necessity.

Pub Date: Sept. 11th, 1991
ISBN: 0-465-06871-5
Page count: 356pp
Publisher: Basic
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 15th, 1991




MORE BY STEPHEN L. CARTER

FictionTHE IMPEACHMENT OF ABRAHAM LINCOLN by Stephen L. Carter
by Stephen L. Carter
NonfictionTHE VIOLENCE OF PEACE by Stephen L. Carter
by Stephen L. Carter
FictionJERICHO’S FALL by Stephen L. Carter
by Stephen L. Carter

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionFOR DISCRIMINATION by Randall Kennedy
by Randall Kennedy