FREIGHT TRAIN TRIP! by Susanna Leonard Hill

FREIGHT TRAIN TRIP!

A Lift-the-Flap Adventure

KIRKUS REVIEW

A laden freight train makes its westbound run, only narrowly missing a collision with an eastbound commuter train. The oversized trim allows for a nice extension of the train and accommodates up to two flaps per spread. These flaps are flimsy things and likely will not last more than a few readings. That’s OK, as the labored verse (“The engine rushes down the track, / with ninety-seven cars in back. / They are full of lumber; toys, and more, / and headed for the western shore”) will drive adult readers round the bend. The excitement of the near-collision is blunted, first by a flap that reveals the successful rail-switching before the text does and then by a concluding, “it’s been fun!” summation. Get another copy of Donald Crews’s Freight Train and give this a miss. (Ages 18 mos.-3)

Pub Date: Sept. 8th, 2009
ISBN: 978-1-4169-7833-6
Page count: 12pp
Publisher: Little Simon/Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 1st, 2009




MORE BY SUSANNA LEONARD HILL

ChildrenAPRIL FOOL, PHYLLIS! by Susanna Leonard Hill
by Susanna Leonard Hill
ChildrenCAN'T SLEEP WITHOUT SHEEP by Susanna Leonard Hill
by Susanna Leonard Hill
ChildrenNOT YET, ROSE by Susanna Leonard Hill
by Susanna Leonard Hill