How the U.S. Military Mismanages Great Leaders and Why It's Time for a Revolution
Email this review


Hudson Institute chief economist Kane proposes the use of market-based methods to reform the military's personnel and pay policies.

The author, a former officer in the U.S. Air Force, argues that the military is losing talent from the officer corps. The institutional structure legislated into effect beginning in the late 1970s has morphed into an unwieldy and counterproductive system that is increasingly abandoned by a number of junior officers. Kane is raising a warning flag about the future quality of the officer corps and the future of the military itself. For him, the problem is located in the promotion system, which is based on seniority, not merit, and “leads to a less competent general-officer corps.” Promotion from the junior-officer level is tied to service, and at each level of advance, the percentage of officers who can move up to the next grade is fixed by law. In the author's view, the ensuing problem is compounded by pension qualifications. Kane advocates a merit-based, entrepreneurial alternative driven by market considerations, and he draws from conservative economists such as Friedrich Hayek to support his case. He favors introducing competition over assignments and requirements and putting control in the hands of the unit commanders, who intimately know their needs. Kane discusses what his ideas of “entrepreneurial” officers would look like, referencing George Washington, George Marshall and Gen. Eisenhower as examples. The author also calls for junior officers to be able to leave service and return later without losing pension rights.

National-budget stringencies will no doubt amplify this intriguing discussion.

Pub Date: Dec. 11th, 2012
ISBN: 978-0-230-39127-7
Page count: 288pp
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 1st, 2012


NonfictionA BIGGER PRIZE by Margaret Heffernan
by Margaret Heffernan
NonfictionHALLIBURTON’S ARMY by Pratap Chatterjee
by Pratap Chatterjee
NonfictionHEARTS AND MINDS by Hannah Gurman
by Hannah Gurman
NonfictionDRIFT by Rachel Maddow
by Rachel Maddow