WHAT IF YOUR BEST FRIEND WERE BLUE? by Vera Kochan

WHAT IF YOUR BEST FRIEND WERE BLUE?

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 4 - 8

KIRKUS REVIEW

This simple picture book is intended to teach both color awareness—of shades such as blue, green and yellow—and color-blindness in terms of skin tones. It doesn’t work.

The book begins by asking, “What if your best friend were blue?” The child narrator answers, “Even if my best friend were blue, he’d still play soccer with me.” The nominal dialogue continues: “What if a policewoman were green?” “Even if a policewoman were green, she’d still help me find my mom and dad.” The book continues exactly like this, featuring a yellow doctor, a purple fireman, a red teacher and an orange babysitter. The intended message of this title is highjacked by two little words, repeated again and again: “even if.” This phrase, suggesting as it does that a best friend would still play soccer despite his blue-ness and the policewoman still provide a helping hand despite her green-ness, does not undermine homogeneity, but rather confirms whiteness as humankind’s default skin color. Further contributing to this notion is the fact that the main character is white, as are all the other adults and children who are not being used to demonstrate a particular color; skin tones aside from white that actually show up in the real world are absent entirely. Even the lessons in identifying colors fall apart here. The policewoman who is supposed to be green actually first appears as an off-putting shade of yellow.

A big miss. (Picture book. 4-8)

Pub Date: Sept. 1st, 2011
ISBN: 978-0-7614-5897-5
Page count: 24pp
Publisher: Marshall Cavendish
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 15th, 2011




MORE BY VIVIANA GAROFOLI

ChildrenTEA TIME by Karen Rostoker-Gruber
by Karen Rostoker-Gruber
ChildrenRAINDROPS by Chiêu Anh Urban
by Chiêu Anh Urban
ChildrenPIRATES! by Viviana Garofoli
by Viviana Garofoli

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTHE SKIN YOU LIVE IN by Michael Tyler
by Michael Tyler
ChildrenSHADES OF PEOPLE by Shelley Rotner
by Shelley Rotner
AdultTHE COLORS OF US by Karen Katz
by Karen Katz