IS MOMMY? by Victoria Chang


by , illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 5
Email this review


A passel of tots discuss their moms' positive and negative aspects with uncontained glee.

"Is mommy tall... / or short?" an unseen narrator asks a crimson-haired tyke wearing a matching crimson dress with white polka dots. The child imagines "tall" (mommy leans down lovingly, about to pick up her dubious-looking daughter) and "short" (now the child looms over a suddenly shrunken, dismayed-looking mommy). With a turn of the page, a definitive, spread-dominating speech bubble declares, "Short!" Other child-and-mommy pairings demonstrate pretty or ugly, nice or mean, fun or boring, young or old, neat or messy; each mommy is loudly adjudged the negative alternative, the growing crowd of children reveling in the mischief. Frazee uses tempera in a limited palette of candy colors, black, and white on soft tan Manila paper, brush strokes giving each area of color (plus the white speech bubbles) luscious texture. The moms look like tall, elongated versions of their children, down to identically colored clothing and hair and distinctive hairstyles. In fluidity of line, simplicity and boldness of palette, and often peculiarity of hairstyle, the figures evoke Seuss’ Whos; in sheer impishness, these children are 100-percent Frazee. When asked, “Do you love your short, ugly, mean, boring, old, messy mommy?” however, there is no question in these children’s minds: “Yes!”

A funny and deceptively simple meditation on unconditional filial love. (Picture book. 3-5)

Pub Date: Nov. 3rd, 2015
ISBN: 978-1-4814-0292-7
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Beach Lane/Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 15th, 2015


ChildrenTHE BOSSIER BABY by Marla Frazee
by Marla Frazee
ChildrenONE AWESOME THING by Sara Pennypacker
by Sara Pennypacker
ChildrenCOMPLETELY CLEMENTINE by Sara Pennypacker
by Sara Pennypacker


ChildrenHUG MACHINE by Scott Campbell
by Scott Campbell
ChildrenTHE ODD EGG by Emily Gravett
by Emily Gravett
ChildrenMOMMY GO AWAY! by Lynne Jonell
by Lynne Jonell