SCUMBLER by William Wharton

SCUMBLER

KIRKUS REVIEW

In Wharton's two best novels, Birdy and Dad, a trapdoor seems to open about halfway through--with the reader suddenly dropped to a startling plane of reality, something very different from the conventional reality suggested by the homely, casual surface tone. In Wharton's unimpressive third novel, however, A Midnight Clear, that trap-door effect seemed to be infinitely deferred, then never happened at all. And here the effect is attempted, but halfheartedly, making this a disappointing book, though far superior to A Midnight Clear. Scumbler is the narrator, an expatriate American painter living in Paris with his wife and whichever of his five children aren't currently in college in California. Scumbler is a "nester" ("slumlord," he admits, would be another way to term it)--fixing up dismal Parisian properties, then renting them out to other artists or to students, occasionally using them himself for studio-space or storage. His paintings don't bring in much money. But Scumbler is property-rich and enjoys his life: the infrequent windfall, his collection of clocks, riding his motorcycle, painting in the streets while flirting with the many women who talk to him. He's a loping, attractive character, vain and impetuous but also quite level in most of the important ways, faithful to family and to art. He believes in the subjective ("true surrealism"); he entertains classically crackpot ideas gracefully, wanting 'to be unhitched from my particular little niche in sequential time and move easily along the boards of continuous time"; he writes small poems so awful they're charming. ("WILLFUL, LAST-DITCH WANDERINGS,/UNFILLED PROMISES LIE HEAVY IN MY SOUL,/BRAIN-FILLED EYES NOT SEEING, NOR KNOWING/THE BLUE OF CLEAR AND CLOUDLESS SKIES.") And, in its low-key way, this is one of the best pictures in contemporary fiction of an unfashionable, probably mediocre, everyday artist. Then, however, comes that trap-door effect, about midway through: Scumbler does a self-portrait ("body with a brain seeing a brain through a body")--and the painted image of himself becomes him, leaves him only a body, collapsed on the floor. But this experience is not repeated; nor is it really developed except in ever fainter resonance--with autobiographical clues (Scumbler is the grown-up Birdy) that Wharton seems ambivalent and/or lazy about providing. Thus, the novel's immanent eerieness remains tantalizingly out-of-reach, with glimmers only for alert Wharton devotees. And the result is, for the most part, no more nor less than a genial, flabby self-portrait of the artist/writer--heavy on set-pieces of middle-aged bohemian apprehension and aw-shucks equability, evocative and often-appealing, but without narrative shape or depth.
Pub Date: May 22nd, 1984
ISBN: 1557042586
Page count: 292pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 15th, 1984




MORE BY WILLIAM WHARTON

NonfictionHOUSEBOAT ON THE SEINE by William Wharton
by William Wharton
NonfictionEVER AFTER by William Wharton
by William Wharton
FictionLAST LOVERS by William Wharton
by William Wharton