Stephen King’s 1974 debut horror novel, Carrie—about an abused and bullied teenage girl who uses telekinetic powers to wreak revenge on her tormentors—has had more than its share of adaptations over the years. Most people are familiar with the intense 1976 film version, directed by Brian De Palma and starring Sissy Spacek; fewer may be aware of a 2002 NBC TV movie, starring Angela Bettis (Girl, Interrupted), and a 2013 theatrical film starring Chloë Grace Moretz (The Peripheral). The novel also provided the basis for a 1988 Broadway musical—a notorious flop that closed after just three days—and a superfluous 1999 movie sequel, The Rage: Carrie 2. That’s so many tales of bloody revenge that one wonders if another trip to Carrie’s prom is strictly necessary. A new, eight-episode Prime Video series, by accomplished horror filmmaker Mike Flanagan, has its moments, but it doesn’t make a strong case for its existence. It premieres on Oct. 7.

A case can be made that none of the adaptations, so far, have done the novel justice. King’s works are such an integral part of the popular culture that it’s hard to remember how fresh, and complex, Carrie was. The basic narrative focuses mainly on Maine high schooler Carietta “Carrie” White, whose devoutly religious, widowed mother, Margaret, frequently berates her and locks her in a closet, forcing her to pray. Carrie’s an outcast at Ewen High School, where her fellow students have long ridiculed the “chunky girl with pimples” who has no friends. When she gets her first period while showering after a gym class, she’s horrified; her mother never told her about menstruation, so she thinks she’s dying—and the other girls, led by the brutal Chris Hargensen, cruelly mock Carrie for it, “bombarding her with tampons and sanitary napkins.” The gym teacher, Miss Desjardins, puts a stop to the abuse and sees to it that all the bullies are punished with detention; the defiant Chris gets banned from the upcoming prom, so she comes up with a plan to humiliate Carrie at the dance, as revenge. “What none of them knew, of course,” notes the narrator, “was that Carrie White was telekinetic,” which results in an unforgettable night of horror.

It’s a simple story, in its broad strokes, but King had larger ambitions than simply telling a tale of supernatural vengeance. Throughout the text, he intersperses fictional newspaper stories and magazine articles, as well as excerpts from government reports and even a character’s memoir, all of which give the story a gripping sense of realism, especially during the latter sections that chronicle the cataclysmic prom night. He also skillfully shows how the massive tragedy forever alters the small town—and the world at large. The result is a kaleidoscopic tour de force that belies its relatively short length, and none of the previous movie versions have ever approached its complexity.

Flanagan is big fan of King’s work who previously helmed movie versions of his Kirkus-starred novels Gerald’s Game and Doctor Sleep, as well as the novella “The Life of Chuck” from King’s collection If It Bleeds. They’re all generally faithful adaptations, and all quite good, to boot. This time around, though, Flanagan generally decided to do his own thing, with mixed results.

In the series, Carrie, played by Summer H. Howell (Hunter Hunter), is attending high school for the first time after a lifetime of homeschooling and little contact with the outside world—due, in part, to the paranoia of her religious, conspiracy-theorist mother (Samantha Sloyan). The bookish teen (who, it bears mentioning, is clear-skinned and thin, unlike King’s character) is excited to meet new people, and although she’s painfully naïve at times, she’s also upbeat, friendly, and open-hearted. One scene, in which Carrie movingly quotes from Emily Winfield Martin’s children’s book The Wonderful Things You Will Be, could thaw the coldest of hearts. Frankly, it’s hard to believe that anyone would make it their life’s mission to bully her—as the loathsome Chris eventually does, in part, by wielding the power of an anonymous Instagram account.

Social media quickly becomes a major focus of the series, and one can imagine this aspect seeming quite dated in just a few years. But it’s not the only new element that Flanagan adds: Carrie also has a mysterious new friend named Emmaline (Thalia Dudek), for instance, who frequently gives her advice. There’s also an initially minor but ultimately significant plotline—featuring a notable performance by Flanagan’s spouse, Kate Siegel, as an interviewer who questions various figures in Carrie’s life—that sends King’s story into territory that recalls David Cronenberg’s 1981 horror classic Scanners.

These changes all work fine, even if they’re not particularly exciting or daring, and there are a number of fine performances, as well: Howell is enormously likable as Carrie and also convincingly handles the character’s darker turns, and Sloyan, an alum of several Flanagan works, gives Carrie’s mom a surprising depth. Alison Thornton (Dare Me) makes Chris, Carrie’s number-one enemy, very easy to hate, and Josie Totah (The Buccaneers) is great as her awful, self-centered pal, Tina. Amber Midthunder (Prey) is also highly relatable as Miss Desjardins, Carrie’s well-meaning but ultimately powerless teacher.

That said, the show doesn’t bring anything to the story that’s especially insightful or compelling. Its analysis of bullying never goes beyond the surface level, and its commentary on the dangers of social media feels trite. The most significant new story elements, involving Siegel’s character, feel woefully underdeveloped. The biggest issue, though, is that this new series simply isn’t very scary. It spends so much time on the Instagram plot, in particular, that all sense of dread evaporates—a fatal omission, as the novel’s power derives, in large part, from its sense of impending doom. In Flanagan’s series, Carrie’s prom night feels more inevitable than terrifying, and, by design, its story has no sense of closure. It’s as if the showrunner forgot that every tragedy has an ending—and no second-season pickup.

David Rapp is the senior Indie editor.