THAT STINKS! by Alan Katz

THAT STINKS!

A Punny Show-and-Tell
by , illustrated by
Age Range: 4 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Katz’s (sub)titular show and tell has a room full of racially diverse students making proclamations that would normally get them sent to the principal’s office, giving this book a forbidden-fruit vibe.

A cold and rainy day prompts Mrs. Mueller to cancel recess and hold show and tell instead. Jimmy’s response? “That stinks!” The class gasps, mouths agape, but Jimmy is just referring to the item he’s sharing: his pet skunk. “Aw, nuts!” says Susie: she shows off a bowl of several kinds. And so it goes, each student turning a potentially inflammatory comment into an innocuous one, though some are more jaw-dropping than others—“This totally bites!”—and some are just downright cheesy (literally). And the nerds are easily pinpointed: Monica shows off her gross of pencils, and Thomas displays an electrical circuit (“Shocking!”). Gilpin proves he is a master of both facial expressions and kids’ body language; a raised eyebrow here and a crinkled nose there exude disgust, and there’s no child who won’t recognize the talk-to-the-hand gesture accompanied by upward-looking eyes that he does so well in his digital illustrations. But Katz’s text is not as strong. One wonders how the kids came to have these items in school (especially the pet skunk and the family’s dinner garbage) when the activity is presented as an impromptu decision. The items also seem to be chosen more for their pun-ability than as a reflection of kids’ reality.

Like a pun, this book will either go over really well or flop. (Picture book. 4-8)

Pub Date: July 12th, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-4169-7880-0
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 2016




MORE BY ALAN KATZ

ChildrenTHE DAY THE MUSTACHE CAME BACK by Alan Katz
by Alan Katz
ChildrenTHE DAY THE MUSTACHE TOOK OVER by Alan Katz
by Alan Katz

MORE BY STEPHEN GILPIN

ChildrenSLINGSHOT AND BURP by Richard Haynes
by Richard Haynes
ChildrenINTO THE WILD by Doreen Cronin
by Doreen Cronin
ChildrenFART SQUAD by Seamus Pilger
by Seamus Pilger

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

AdultWORD PLAY ABC by Heather Cahoon
by Heather Cahoon
ChildrenCHICKEN LILY by Lori Mortensen
by Lori Mortensen
ChildrenMY DAD THINKS HE'S FUNNY by Katrina Germein
by Katrina Germein