RABBI BENJAMIN'S BUTTONS by Alice B. McGinty

RABBI BENJAMIN'S BUTTONS

Age Range: 4 - 8

KIRKUS REVIEW

This story will feel familiar to many readers, and some of them will find that oddly disconcerting.

There’s a famous Jewish folk tale: A man’s coat is wearing out, so he tailors it into a vest and, as it gets even older, into a button. When that button finally wears out, he’s left with only the story. McGinty’s book reads like that folk tale turned inside out. A rabbi’s congregation buys him a vest with beautiful silver buttons. Over the course of a year, the vest becomes more and more timeworn, and as the rabbi eats delicious holiday meals, the buttons pop off, first one at a time and then two at once. But there’s a surprise: The congregation has collected the buttons and sewn them onto a brand-new vest, even more beautiful than the old one. The inverted story is charming, if a little slight, but it may seem familiar for another reason. The use of language is often trite and sometimes mawkish. The expression “A happy congregation is the sunshine of my heart” appears with variations throughout the book. The book’s less sentimental readers may find they prefer the earlier folk tale. But Reinhardt’s watercolor-and-ink drawings are strange and captivating. The rabbi’s beard seems to point in two directions at once.

Every reader, sentimental or not, can enjoy the many holiday recipes at the end of the book. (glossary) (Picture book. 4-8)

Pub Date: Aug. 5th, 2014
ISBN: 978-1-58089-432-6
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Charlesbridge
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2014




MORE BY ALICE B. MCGINTY

ChildrenGANDHI by Alice B. McGinty
by Alice B. McGinty
ChildrenDARWIN by Alice B. McGinty
by Alice B. McGinty
ChildrenTHANK YOU, WORLD by Alice B. McGinty
by Alice B. McGinty

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenCAN HENS GIVE MILK? by Joan Betty Stuchner
by Joan Betty Stuchner
ChildrenTHE ROOSTER PRINCE OF BRESLOV by Ann Redisch Stampler
by Ann Redisch Stampler
ChildrenKIBITZERS AND FOOLS by Simms Taback
by Simms Taback