A CAST IS THE PERFECT ACCESSORY by Allison Gutknecht

A CAST IS THE PERFECT ACCESSORY

(And Other Lessons I've Learned)
by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 7 - 10
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Eight-year-old Mandy is back, as bossy and insecure as ever (Don’t Wear Polka-Dot Underwear with White Pants, 2013).

In the second installment in this chapter-book series, Mandy’s friendship with Anya is in jeopardy. Goody-goody Natalie steals Mandy’s thunder again—this time by breaking her wrist. Their teacher assigns Anya to be Natalie’s assistant, which leaves little time for Mandy and Anya to play. Mandy’s jealous reaction to seeing Anya with another friend is to retreat, pout and be, as her mother says, a “crankypants.” Mandy’s behavior threatens to overwhelm the book right from the beginning. In the first chapter alone, she eats a bit out of each piece of pizza in the box, calls her father a “bad babysitter,” demands gummy bears and “fancy-dancy periwinkle sunglasses” of her grandmother, and calls her little brother “stupid.” It’s easy to see why she clings to Anya so fiercely, but this does not make Mandy any more likable. Young readers might learn a little from Mandy, but it’s unlikely that they would choose her as a friend. More likely, they will empathize with poor Anya, pulled between a smothering BFF and a new buddy. The all-too-simple resolution is a relief, but it’s also completely unbelievable.

Even the most wayward child readers would agree that Mandy needs stronger adult direction. (Fiction. 7-10)

Pub Date: March 4th, 2014
ISBN: 978-1-4424-8396-5
Page count: 160pp
Publisher: Aladdin
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15th, 2014




MORE BY ALLISON GUTKNECHT

ChildrenSING LIKE NOBODY'S LISTENING by Allison Gutknecht
by Allison Gutknecht

MORE BY STEVIE LEWIS

ChildrenPRINCE & KNIGHT by Daniel Haack
by Daniel Haack
ChildrenBLUEBERRY PANCAKES FOREVER by Angelica Banks
by Angelica Banks
ChildrenA WEEK WITHOUT TUESDAY by Angelica Banks
by Angelica Banks

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenGOONEY BIRD GREENE by Lois Lowry
by Lois Lowry
ChildrenCLEMENTINE by Sara Pennypacker
by Sara Pennypacker
ChildrenJUDY MOODY by Megan McDonald
by Megan McDonald