Somehow I Am Different by Alyssa Petersel
Kirkus Star

Somehow I Am Different

Narratives of Searching and Belonging in Jewish Budapest
Email this review


Petersel’s debut explores the revitalization of the Hungarian Jewish community in 21 oral histories of millennial Jews.

Young Hungarians in cafes, synagogues, festivals, and conferences tell of their Jewish religious and cultural identities in this work. They include an Orthodox rabbi, a chef, a rapper, children of Holocaust survivors, a non-Jew with an anti-Semitic past considering conversion, and others, and their diverse personal and work histories result in multifaceted tales. Each person’s story demonstrates his or her winding path to embracing Judaism, whether it be in a historical context or in present-day Hungary. Some interviewees see a primary need to educate people about the Holocaust and anti-Semitism; others want to dispel images of Jews as victims and let the world know about the currently thriving Hungarian Jewish culture. Asuzsanna Fritz, who was unaware that she was Jewish until she was 16, explains, “we decided that we could create a positive Jewish identification. We created an open door and said whoever wants to come, we are happy to receive you.” Such visions of flourishing communities are tempered, though, by the recent rise of the right wing; the country is “becoming more and more nationalistic and conservative…more and more excluding toward minorities,” says one young adult. “The question is: Do I want to live in a country where the main tendency and the main values are not what I believe in?...I don’t have a clear answer for that.” With deft prose, Petersel seamlessly weaves together Jewish voices with evocative descriptions of the sights, sounds, and smells of her Hungarian surroundings. Her depictions of food, for example, induce pangs of hunger: “spicy mushrooms ignited my palate and my sinuses. Hints of sharp cheese mixed with the comfort of potatoes in the French stew.” An epilogue features excerpts of Petersel’s own journal and a contributed essay by Ákos Keller-Alánt on Hungary’s contemporary history, politics, and economy, which adds an important component to the work. Although the book focuses on Hungarian Jewish life, its historical context, provocative questions about identity and culture, and captivating writing will engage and educate a very broad audience.

A journey through the lives of young Eastern European Jews that’s not to be missed.

Pub Date: March 17th, 2016
ISBN: 978-0-692-58411-8
Page count: 342pp
Publisher: Acorn Publishing
Program: Kirkus Indie
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2016


IndieSomehow I Am Different by Alyssa Petersel
by Alyssa Petersel
IndieGerald's Journal by David McElhinny
by David McElhinny
IndieThe Oath by Stephen Robert Stein
by Stephen Robert Stein
IndieThe Finite Woman by Mark Salamon
by Mark Salamon


AdultTHE BUDAPEST FILE by George Szirtes
by George Szirtes
NonfictionWHY BE JEWISH? by Edgar M. Bronfman
by Edgar M. Bronfman
NonfictionA HOLE IN THE HEART OF THE WORLD by Jonathan Kaufman
by Jonathan Kaufman