Best of the Small Presses
edited by
Email this review


The 25th anniversary edition of a tradition in American literature, heavier on quantity than quality but still worth perusing for some showstoppers.

Henderson’s introduction alone makes for worthwhile reading: the cast of beginning editors he names reads like the list for a literary hall of fame, and his history of the prize charts a recent trajectory of publishing at large. Among this year’s entries, essays, memoirs, and short stories dominate, with poems interspersed like an unfortunate form of punctuation: Cathleen Calbert’s “Bad Judgement,” with its dazzling and vibrant rhythm and flow, and the brutally full-bore “Six Apologies, Lord” by Olena Kalytiak Davis, among a few others, are strong exceptions. But it is a dozen or so short stories and a few memoirs and essays that deserve special recognition. Standouts include Salvatore Scibona’s “Prairie” (which evokes the solitary feel of growing up the Canadian prairie), Ken Kalfus’s “PU-239” (which tells of a nuclear reactor technician with nothing to lose), and other impressive inclusions (such as Kathleen Hill’s “The Annointed,” Jane McCaffrey’s “Berna’s Place,” and Joan Silber’s “Commendable”). Memoirs are surprisingly good: Bret Lott’s “Toward Humility” is notable, as well as Andrew Hudgins’s “Half-Answered Prayers.” And there is literary criticism, as well: in “Milton at the Bat,” Jeffrey Hammond writes a defense of Milton that reads like a modern-day defense of poetry. It is ironic that Hammond’s piece shares the stage with Seamus Heaney’s “New Staves” (an attempt to answer the question “What good is poetry?”), since a comparison of the two illustrates the imbalance that appears throughout the collection: while Heaney’s answer feels flat and rote, Hammond’s is enthusiastic and convincing.

Seventy-four entries were selected out of over 5,000 nominations. Another cut might well have been made, but there is wheat here among the chaff.

Pub Date: Nov. 1st, 2000
ISBN: 1-888889-22-5
Page count: 620pp
Publisher: Pushcart
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1st, 2000


FictionTHE PUSHCART PRIZE XLII by Bill Henderson
by Bill Henderson
FictionTHE PUSHCART PRIZE XLI by Bill Henderson
by Bill Henderson
FictionTHE PUSHCART PRIZE XL by Bill Henderson
by Bill Henderson