SHE IS ME by Cathleen Schine

SHE IS ME

Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Three generations of a close-knit family—mother, daughter, and granddaughter, each supporting the other selflessly but nevertheless facing her greatest challenge alone.

Best known for The Love Letter (1995), which became a movie, Schine (The Evolution of Jane, 1998, etc.) focuses this time on three women: Lotte, the matriarch of a Jewish family transplanted to California, has recently been diagnosed with facial skin cancer. Her daughter Greta, a landscape artist married to a nice if slightly abstract doctor, adores her mother and does not resent caring for Lotte. Elizabeth, Greta’s daughter, is an academic in New York, but by lucky coincidence she has been hired by the movie mogul Larry Volfman, a secret intellectual, to adapt Madame Bovary for the screen. With her loving boyfriend, whom she won’t commit to marry, and their excessively lovable three-year-old son Harry, she moves to LA just in time to help care for Lotte, who is, as she herself likes to repeat, “a pistol,” as elegant and feisty as ever. Earthy, nurturing Greta is thrilled to have her daughter near but keeps her feelings in check. Elizabeth’s life, complete with a big salary, a cottage in Venice, and an SUV, seems almost perfect. Then Greta is diagnosed with colon cancer. She keeps her own cancer a secret from Lotte, but Elizabeth must step in and help both patients more. She’s exhausted, pulled by conflicting responsibilities. As Lotte very privately comes to grips with her approaching death, Elizabeth finds herself attracted both to Volfman and to her younger brother’s best friend, even though Brett is the most patient and loving of romantic heroes. Meanwhile, Greta not only struggles with chemotherapy but with her growing, out-of-the-blue passion for Daisy Piperino, the female director with whom Elizabeth is working. There are many references to Flaubert’s novel, but Schine’s domestic melodrama is short on real drama, with characters all too nice and understanding to create more than a mild stir.

Capable but bland.

Pub Date: Sept. 15th, 2003
ISBN: 0-316-78609-8
Page count: 288pp
Publisher: Little, Brown
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2003




MORE BY CATHLEEN SCHINE

FictionTHEY MAY NOT MEAN TO, BUT THEY DO by Cathleen Schine
by Cathleen Schine
FictionFIN & LADY by Cathleen Schine
by Cathleen Schine
FictionTHE THREE WEISSMANNS OF WESTPORT by Cathleen Schine
by Cathleen Schine