NO OTHER STORY by Cuthbert  Soup

NO OTHER STORY

Age Range: 11 - 13
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A once-entertaining tale about a widowed inventor who goes on the lam with his three above-average children (until he can finish building a time machine to dispel an ancient family curse and prevent his wife’s murder) drags its way to a conclusion.

Having taken care of the curse in the middle episode, Another Whole Nother Story (2010), "Soup" evidently finds that even with extensive padding—including an irrelevant flashback chapter and bit parts for the uncommonly intrusive author/narrator himself and his deaf mother—the culminating rescue makes only half a book. Accordingly, the author fills out the page count with a long and aimless stopover for the time-traveling Cheeseman family. This takes place in Some Times, an interdimensional mashup of eras, places and seasons where the Cheeseman children get glimpses of their futures from a worshipful descendent. Meanwhile, their father, convinced he’s Gioachino Rossini after a knock to the head, furiously (re)composes the William Tell Overture. The Dave Barry–like flurries of sententious tangents that previously added refreshing interludes of silliness to the storyline come across here as dull and labored, as do the heavy-handed caricatures of various corporate and government pursuers who are the tale’s villains.

Happy and (more or less) logical resolution aside, thin Soup. (Fantasy. 11-13)

Pub Date: Sept. 18th, 2012
ISBN: 978-1-59990-824-3
Page count: 256pp
Publisher: Bloomsbury
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2012




MORE BY CUTHBERT SOUP

ChildrenANOTHER WHOLE NOTHER STORY by Cuthbert  Soup
by Cuthbert Soup
ChildrenA WHOLE NOTHER STORY by Cuthbert  Soup
by Cuthbert Soup

MORE BY JEFFREY STEWART TIMMINS

ChildrenLAST LAUGHS by J. Patrick Lewis
by J. Patrick Lewis
ChildrenLAST LAUGHS by J. Patrick Lewis
by J. Patrick Lewis
ChildrenANOTHER WHOLE NOTHER STORY by Cuthbert  Soup
by Cuthbert Soup
ChildrenA WHOLE NOTHER STORY by Cuthbert  Soup
by Cuthbert Soup

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenA TALE DARK & GRIMM by Adam Gidwitz
by Adam Gidwitz
ChildrenCOLD CEREAL by Adam Rex
by Adam Rex
ChildrenJUMPMAN by James Valentine
by James Valentine