ALL THE WILD THAT REMAINS by David Gessner
Kirkus Star

ALL THE WILD THAT REMAINS

Edward Abbey, Wallace Stegner, and the American West
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

The lives and legacies of two influential environmentalists.

Gessner (Creative Writing/Univ. of North Carolina, Wilmington; The Tarball Chronicles: A Journey Beyond the Oiled Pelican and into the Heart of the Gulf Oil Spill, 2011, etc.) weaves together biography, cultural criticism, travel and nature writing in this engaging record of a journey to discover the American West and two of the region’s most prominent celebrants: Pulitzer Prize–winning writer Wallace Stegner (1909-1993) and Guggenheim Fellow Edward Abbey (1927-1989). Besides reading the two men’s published works, Gessner visited the places in which they lived; interviewed family, friends, co-workers and students; and mined their manuscripts. Although both men felt passionately about the West and their commitment to environmentalism, they were starkly different: “Saint Wallace the Good” was the “intellectual godfather” of Western writers, “the man of order, the man of culture.” He taught at the University of Wisconsin and Harvard, founded Stanford’s creative writing program, patiently sat on environmental committees, and was a devoted husband and father. “ ‘Radical,’ ” Gessner discovered, “was a word he came to despise.” Abbey, scruffy and combative, was the “the man of wildness, the counterculturalist…serious about his anarchism,” who carried out—and incited—acts of environmental sabotage. Married five times and a desultory father to five children, he was “more beatnik than cowboy…right down to the jugs of wine and many women.” Yet for all their differences in style, they converged in recognizing the increasing vulnerability of the West to drought, fires, fracking and overwhelming tourism. They both battled romantic Western myths of cowboy culture and rugged individualism. Those myths and a “lyric celebration of nature,” Stegner argued, undermined effective environmentalism, which should be focused on practical steps for ensuring responsible land use.

Stegner and Abbey “are two who have lighted my way,” nature writer Wendell Berry admitted. They have lighted the way for Gessner, as well, as he conveys in this graceful, insightful homage to their work and to the region they loved.

Pub Date: April 20th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0393089998
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Norton
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 1st, 2015




BEST NATURE & TRAVEL BOOKS OF 2015:

NonfictionTHE INVENTION OF NATURE by Andrea Wulf
by Andrea Wulf
NonfictionPACIFIC by Simon Winchester
by Simon Winchester
NonfictionALL THE WRONG PLACES by Philip Connors
by Philip Connors
NonfictionTHE WHITE ROAD by Edmund de Waal
by Edmund de Waal

MORE BY DAVID GESSNER

NonfictionMY GREEN MANIFESTO by David Gessner
by David Gessner
NonfictionSOARING WITH FIDEL by David Gessner
by David Gessner
NonfictionRETURN OF THE OSPREY by David Gessner
by David Gessner

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionFINDING ABBEY by Sean Prentiss
by Sean Prentiss
NonfictionROAD TRIP by Mark Rozema
by Mark Rozema
NonfictionCADILLAC DESERT by Marc Reisner
by Marc Reisner