Next book

THE TOOTH FAIRY

A spooky, strange, and enjoyable supernatural novel.

Awards & Accolades

Our Verdict

  • Our Verdict
  • GET IT

Tarsitano offers a macabre tale of terror and teeth.

At the opening of this psychological thriller, Johnny Hawk is tied to an old dentist’s chair in a basement, terrified and injured, horrified that his “teeth were gone—and not the ones that were supposed to go.” Readers learn through flashbacks and chapters told from other characters’ points of view that Hawk’s life was thrown into chaos after he discovered his wife was having an affair with another man, leaving him feeling like “a voiceless spectator in a red-light theatre that was playing the movie about the failure of his life.” He eventually heads out toward Los Angeles by car, picking up a hitchhiker and friend along the way, before crossing paths in New Mexico with dentist Wendy Jag after a painful tooth causes him to nearly crash his car. Readers soon learn that she’s actually the novel’s titular character—a sadistic, evil being. Tarsitano’s debut novel unfolds largely in fictional Copper City, which one supporting character describes as cursed; it holds many dark secrets and is, in some ways, reminiscent of Stephen King’s Castle Rock, Maine. Readers of suspense will enjoy Jag’s unnerving backstory as well as the friendships between Hawk and some of the other supporting characters (particularly Jamie, the hitchhiker). Some elements will specifically remind readers of The Shining (1977) and The Dark Half (1989), including its creepy talismans, such as an object left at Jag’s father’s gravesite, “a small pearl, lodged in a thin strip of fresh dirt,” that turns out to be a child’s tooth. There’s some solid horror writing here, with a style that has considerable bite.

A spooky, strange, and enjoyable supernatural novel.

Pub Date: March 1, 2022

ISBN: 978-0-578-38595-2

Page Count: 280

Publisher: Self

Review Posted Online: May 9, 2022

Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1, 2022

Next book

YOU'D LOOK BETTER AS A GHOST

Squeamish readers will find this isn’t their cup of tea.

Dexter meets Killing Eve in Wallace’s dark comic thriller debut.

While accepting condolences following her father’s funeral, 30-something narrator Claire receives an email saying that one of her paintings is a finalist for a prize. But her joy is short-circuited the next morning when she learns in a second apologetic note that the initial email had been sent to the wrong Claire. The sender, Lucas Kane, is “terribly, terribly sorry” for his mistake. Claire, torn between her anger and suicidal thoughts, has doubts about his sincerity and stalks him to a London pub, where his fate is sealed: “I stare at Lucas Kane in real life, and within moments I know. He doesn’t look sorry.” She dispatches and buries Lucas in her back garden, but this crime does not go unnoticed. Proud of her meticulous standards as a serial killer, Claire wonders if her grief for her father is making her reckless as she seeks to identify the blackmailer among the members of her weekly bereavement support group. The female serial killer as antihero is a growing subgenre (see Oyinkan Braithwaite’s My Sister, the Serial Killer, 2018), and Wallace’s sociopathic protagonist is a mordantly amusing addition; the tool she uses to interact with ordinary people while hiding her homicidal nature is especially sardonic: “Whenever I’m unsure of how I’m expected to respond, I use a cliché. Even if I’m not sure what it means, even if I use it incorrectly, no one ever seems to mind.” The well-written storyline tackles some tough subjects—dementia, elder abuse, and parental cruelty—but the convoluted plot starts to drag at the halfway point. Given the lack of empathy in Claire’s narration, most of the characters come across as not very likable, and the reader tires of her sneering contempt.

Squeamish readers will find this isn’t their cup of tea.

Pub Date: April 16, 2024

ISBN: 9780143136170

Page Count: 336

Publisher: Penguin

Review Posted Online: Feb. 3, 2024

Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1, 2024

Next book

DAUGHTER OF MINE

Small-town claustrophobia and intimacies alike propel this twist-filled psychological thriller.

The loss of her police officer father and the discovery of an abandoned car in a local lake raise chilling questions regarding a young woman’s family history.

When Hazel Sharp returns to her hometown of Mirror Lake, North Carolina, for her father’s memorial, she and the other townspeople are confronted by a challenging double whammy: As they’re grieving the loss of beloved longtime police officer Detective Perry Holt, a disturbing sight appears in the lake, whose waterline is receding because of an ongoing drought—an old, unidentifiable car, which has likely been lurking there for years. Hazel temporarily leaves her Charlotte-based building-renovation business in the capable hands of her partners and reconnects with her brothers, Caden and Gage; her Uncle Roy; her old fling and neighbor, Nico; and her schoolfriend, Jamie, now a mother and married to Caden. Tiny, relentless suspicions rise to the metaphorical surface along with that waterlogged vehicle: There have been a slew of minor break-ins; two people go missing; and then, a second abandoned car is discovered. The novel digs deeper into Hazel’s family history—her father was a widow when he married Hazel’s mother, who later left the family, absconding with money and jewels—and Miranda, a consummate professional when it comes to exposing the small community tensions that naturally arise when people live in close proximity for generations, exposes revelation after twisty revelation: “Everything mattered disproportionately in a small town. Your success, but also your failure. Everyone knows might as well have been our town motto.”

Small-town claustrophobia and intimacies alike propel this twist-filled psychological thriller.

Pub Date: April 9, 2024

ISBN: 9781668010440

Page Count: 368

Publisher: Marysue Rucci Books

Review Posted Online: Feb. 3, 2024

Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 1, 2024

Close Quickview