SEARCH FOR A METHOD by Hazel E. Barnes

SEARCH FOR A METHOD

translated by , by

KIRKUS REVIEW

This is part of a large scale Critique of Dialectical Reason in which Sartre, French eminence grise, formally acknowledges Marxism as the 20th century's only philosophy and existentialism as a subordinate ideology working within it. The bases are suspect, the arguments shopworn. For Sartre, existentialism is a parasitical system living on the margin of Marxism; in the past it opposed it, now it seeks membership. And what is that but a parallel to Christian assimilation of pagan symbology? Truth is a becoming; totalization is what it becomes, and Marxism is "history itself becoming conscious of itself"- which is Hegelian double-talk all over again. Man is not unknowable: we must develop a "philosophical anthropology". The 18th century Idea of Reason and/or Pavlovian mechanics. Of course Sartre is against both; more perplexity. The scarcity problem is both in economics and emotions and shall be eliminated through collective means; the new fundamental of freedom is Marxist need, not bourgeois desire. Thus, the further juggling of terms and terms. Contradiction is the dialectic and class structure is the contradiction; the capitalist crises produce proletarian class consciousness and rebellion. But except in pre-industrial situations such as Czarist Russia, where has that ever happened? In short, knowledge is Marxism and all of us are Marxists whether we like it or not. And what deep that resemble except Christ as the Indivisible Historical Truth? He died for you, boys; like it or not His death (the Incarnation/Resurrection) is your Meaning. All men are brothers, said Christ. There will be no classes, said Marx. And Sartre, self-hating petit-bourgeois, attempts to escape his class via the Marxist Good News. Unfortunately only the most rigorous, rapier-sharp scrutiny justifies such propositions being elucidated, elongated. And that's not here. Sartre's Method seems continually in double focus: polemical bursts of sunlight along with endless skywriting on a cloudy day. A cognoscenti conversation piece.
Pub Date: June 17th, 1963
ISBN: 0394704649
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 1963




MORE BY HAZEL E. BARNES

NonfictionTHE STORY I TELL MYSELF by Hazel E. Barnes
by Hazel E. Barnes
NonfictionEXISTENTIAL PSYCHOANALYSIS by Hazel E. Barnes
by Hazel E. Barnes

MORE BY JEAN-PAUL SARTRE

NonfictionWE HAVE ONLY THIS LIFE TO LIVE by Jean-Paul Sartre
by Jean-Paul Sartre
NonfictionQUIET MOMENTS IN A WAR by Jean-Paul Sartre
by Jean-Paul Sartre
NonfictionWITNESS TO MY LIFE by Jean-Paul Sartre
by Jean-Paul Sartre