EARTH GIRL by Janet Edwards
Kirkus Star

EARTH GIRL

Age Range: 11 - 16

KIRKUS REVIEW

A disabled teen archaeologist works in fascinating, hazardous conditions on a far-future Earth.

It’s 2789. Humanity lives on numerous planets. Transportation, including between star systems, merely requires stepping into a portal—even schoolchildren do a “mass off-world kiddie commute” daily. But off-world atmospheres are fatal for the rare babies born Handicapped, who are portalled to Earth within minutes and must stay forever. Parents tend to disappear, unwilling to live on Earth just to raise a “throwback.” Earth provides those on its Handicapped wards full care, education and career choice, but Jarra’s bitter that “exos” (non-Handicapped norms) consider her an “ape,” “the garbage of the universe.” Enrolling in a Pre-history course that’s taught on Earth but administered by an off-world university, Jarra plans to quench her thirst for history while teaching some exos a lesson. Terrific nitty-gritty details limn her team’s excavations of a high-risk dig site that was once Manhattan. Although readers won’t see disabilities they recognize, Edwards successfully shows that being physically unable to partake in society’s core structure equals disability. Jarra slides temporarily—implausibly—from matter-of-fact first-person narrator to a character in denial of her reality, but more important are perilous rescues, Jarra’s skills, a solar superstorm that closes portals and endangers hundreds of Military, and some humorous romance with sparkling chemistry.

Action, rich archaeological detail and respectfully levelheaded disability portrayal, refreshingly free from symbolism and magical cures, make this stand out. (Science fiction. 11-16)

Pub Date: March 5th, 2013
ISBN: 978-1-61614-765-5
Page count: 276pp
Publisher: Pyr/Prometheus Books
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 1st, 2013




BEST TEEN FANTASY AND SCIENCE FICTION OF 2013:

ChildrenTHE COLDEST GIRL IN COLDTOWN by Holly Black
by Holly Black
ChildrenSORROW'S KNOT by Erin Bow
by Erin Bow
ChildrenEARTH GIRL by Janet Edwards
by Janet Edwards
ChildrenFIREBORN by Toby Forward
by Toby Forward
ChildrenTHE SUMMER PRINCE by Alaya Dawn Johnson
by Alaya Dawn Johnson

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTIN STAR by Cecil Castellucci
by Cecil Castellucci
ChildrenSINGING THE DOGSTAR BLUES by Alison Goodman
by Alison Goodman
ChildrenIF STONES COULD SPEAK by Marc Aronson
by Marc Aronson
ChildrenSTONE IN THE SKY by Cecil Castellucci
by Cecil Castellucci