CLIFF HANGER by Jean Craighead George

CLIFF HANGER

Age Range: 4 - 8

KIRKUS REVIEW

A disappointing effort from this well-respected pair. Headstrong young Axel defies his father and faces down an impending storm and a challenging climb up what appears to be a sheer rock face to rescue his stranded little dog. So far, so good. Unfortunately, the tension of the text is not well reflected in the illustrations, in which characters resemble plastic action figures, with smooth, molded, pink legs, hands forever frozen in a semi-cupped position, and feet eternally encased in painted-on shoes. Perhaps the lightning-lit images are meant to evoke the stop-frame staccato of a violent storm, but the bone-dry condition of the climb, the fine, fluffy fur of the dog, and their sun-soaked descent on Cathedral Wall would seem to contradict this. Unlikely, too, is the inaction of Axel’s father, Dag, the leader of the Teton Mountains Climbing School and presumably an expert on the pleasures and perils of climbing. Why would an experienced, responsible climber and loving father allow his son to ignore his safe, alternative plan to reach the dog? No explanatory matter is offered to describe or depict the climbing equipment and terminology that figure large in following the storyline, and the illustrations do not make them obvious. With this team and this title, the reader anticipates fine, high adventure and painterly interpretations of environment. Despite its lightweight treatment of what could have been a compelling story, dog-lovers, weather-watchers, and budding adventurers may appreciate this additional purchase. (Picture book. 4-8)

Pub Date: May 1st, 2002
ISBN: 0-06-000260-3
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: HarperCollins
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2002




JEAN CRAIGHEAD GEORGE, 1919-2012:

Children THE BUFFALO ARE BACK by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George
Adult SNOW BEAR by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George
Adult MORNING, NOON, AND NIGHT by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George
Children THE MISSING 'GATOR OF GUMBO LIMBO by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George

MORE BY JEAN CRAIGHEAD GEORGE

ChildrenGALÁPAGOS GEORGE by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George
ChildrenICE WHALE by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George
ChildrenA SPECIAL GIFT FOR GRAMMY by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George

MORE BY WENDELL MINOR

ChildrenGALÁPAGOS GEORGE by Jean Craighead George
by Jean Craighead George
ChildrenHOW BIG COULD YOUR PUMPKIN GROW? by Wendell Minor
by Wendell Minor
ChildrenIF YOU WERE A PANDA BEAR by Florence Minor
by Florence Minor