KIRKUS REVIEW
Irving’s new doorstopper (Until I Find You, 2006, etc.) addresses a strong theme—the role accident plays in even the most carefully planned and managed lives—but doesn’t always stick to the subject.
His logjam of a narrative focuses on the life and times of Danny Baciagalupo, who navigates the roiling waters of growing up alongside his widowed father Dominic, a crippled logging-camp cook employed by a company that plies its dangerous trade along the zigzag Twisted River, north of New Hampshire’s Androscoggin River in Robert Frost’s old neighborhood of Coos County. The story begins swiftly and compellingly in 1954, when a river accident claims the life of teenaged Canadian sawmill worker Angel Pope, whom none of his co-workers really know. Irving’s characters live in a “world of accidents” whose by-products include Dominic’s maiming and the death of his young wife in a mishap similar to Angel’s. All is nicely done throughout the novel’s assured and precisely detailed early pages. But trouble looms and symbols clash when Danny mistakenly thinks a constable’s lady friend is a bear, and admirers of The Cider House Rules (1985) and A Prayer for Owen Meany (1989) will anticipate that Large Meanings prowl these dark woods. The narrative flattens out as we follow the Baciagalupos south to Boston, thence to Iowa (where we’re treated to a lengthy account of Danny’s studies, surely not unlike Irving’s own, at the Iowa Writers’ Workshop), and an enormity of specifics and generalizations about Danny’s career as bestselling author “Danny Angel.” The tale spans 50 years, and Danny’s/Irving’s penchant for commentary on the psyche, obligations and disappointments of the writer’s life makes those years feel like centuries.
Will entertain the faithful and annoy readers who think this author has already written the same novel too many times.
