THE MEANEST BIRTHDAY GIRL by Josh Schneider
Kirkus Star

THE MEANEST BIRTHDAY GIRL

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 6 - 9

KIRKUS REVIEW

Little Dana needs big lessons in kindness more than any birthday present—unless a present can teach her something, that is.

She starts her special day wearing her favorite dress and eating her favorite breakfast, and then, because it’s her birthday “and she could do whatever she liked,” she teases a boy named Anthony. She calls him “ickaborse” and pinches him, and she eats his dessert after her own at school. She later receives many gifts at her party, but none compares with the present Anthony brings after her guests depart: “a big white elephant.” Dana is overwhelmed by the gift’s specialness and is determined to prove her worthiness of the creature, since, as she tells other children, “Not everyone deserves an elephant.” Her dogged efforts result in exhaustion, and with it, Dana becomes a target for another mean girl’s teasing. When audible hunger pangs plague her after she gives up her breakfast to the voracious elephant, for example, “Gertrude called her Grumble-Guts on the bus.” The chagrined Dana talks with Anthony, who generously reminds her about Gertrude’s coming birthday party, and it seems she’s found another birthday girl who deserves an elephant. Throughout, Schneider’s multimedia illustrations employ the same humorous, expressive line seen in his Geisel Award–winning Tales for Very Picky Eaters (2011), delivering a remarkable package.

A gift of a book for new readers. (Early reader. 6-9)

Pub Date: May 7th, 2013
ISBN: 978-0-547-83814-4
Page count: 48pp
Publisher: Clarion
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2013




MORE BY JOSH SCHNEIDER

ChildrenPRINCESS SPARKLE-HEART GETS A MAKEOVER by Josh Schneider
by Josh Schneider
ChildrenTALES FOR VERY PICKY EATERS by Josh Schneider
by Josh Schneider
ChildrenYOU’LL BE SORRY by Josh Schneider
by Josh Schneider

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTALES FOR VERY PICKY EATERS by Josh Schneider
by Josh Schneider
ChildrenTHE BEST PET OF ALL by David LaRochelle
by David LaRochelle
ChildrenUNCLE ELEPHANT by Arnold Lobel
by Arnold Lobel