THE MEMORY KEEPER’S DAUGHTER by Kim Edwards

THE MEMORY KEEPER’S DAUGHTER

KIRKUS REVIEW

One well-intentioned lie causes deep fissures in a family.

David Henry had a hard childhood in West Virginia. His family was dirt poor and his sister June, always sickly, died of a heart defect at 12. Vowing to do good, David left home to become an orthopedic surgeon in Lexington, Ky. He’s 33 when he meets Norah Asher in a department store. The year is 1964, and it’s love at first sight. David delivers his and Norah’s own twins—a boy (Paul) who’s fine, and a girl (Phoebe) who is damaged with Down’s syndrome. Hoping to spare her the pain he underwent with his sister, David tells Norah that the girl is stillborn and instructs his nurse, Caroline, to deliver the infant to an institution. Secretly in love with David, Caroline, who is shocked by his subterfuge and shocked again by the grim shelter, decides to move away and raise Phoebe on her own. Over the next 25 years, parallel stories unfold. In Lexington, the loss of the supposedly dead baby corrodes David and Norah’s marriage. Neither they nor son Paul can be warmed by life together, each keeping busy with pet projects. In Pittsburgh, meanwhile, Caroline lands on her feet, securing a good job and a good man, and raising Phoebe with a fierce devotion. Unfortunately, after its fast and sure-footed start, the story sags: Edwards insists heavy-handedly on the consequences of David’s lie but fails to deliver any true catharsis, and when David does confess, it’s not to Norah. Visiting his childhood home, he is surprised by a squatter, a pregnant runaway of 16 who ties him up—and his story tumbles out. It’s a bold scene, rekindling the excitement of the start yet remaining a solitary flash in a humdrum progression. When the family finally learns the truth, the impact is minimal.

First-novelist Edwards (stories: The Secrets of a Fire King, 1997) excels at celebrating a quiet wholesomeness but stumbles over her storyline.

Pub Date: June 27th, 2005
ISBN: 0-670-03416-9
Page count: 400pp
Publisher: Viking
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 15th, 2005




MORE BY KIM EDWARDS

FictionTHE LAKE OF DREAMS by Kim Edwards
by Kim Edwards
FictionTHE SECRETS OF A FIRE KING by Kim Edwards
by Kim Edwards

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionTHE SALT GOD'S DAUGHTER by Ilie Ruby
by Ilie Ruby
IndieWHEN THE DE LA CRUZ FAMILY DANCED by Donna Miscolta
by Donna Miscolta
IndieTHE WHIPPING CLUB by Deborah Henry
by Deborah Henry