THE PRICE OF JUSTICE by Laurence Leamer


A True Story of Two Lawyers' Epic Battle Against Corruption and Greed in Coal Country
Email this review


A well-constructed nonfiction legal thriller from prizewinning journalist Leamer (Madness Under the Royal Palms: Love and Death Behind the Gates of Palm Beach, 2009, etc.).

In 1998, Harman Coal Company, owned by Hugh Caperton, was destroyed in what was proven through the court system to have been a fraudulent declaration of “force majeure” by Donald Blankenship, then chairman of the massive coal company Massey Energy, one of the largest employers in West Virginia. Leamer uses the more than 14 years of court battles, organized by Dave Fawcett and Bruce Stanley, Caperton’s Pittsburgh lawyers, as the scaffold on which he unfolds this amazing account of contemporary political corruption, skulduggery and mayhem, a situation compared by the New York Times to John Grisham's courtroom drama The Appeal. When, in 2002, Blankenship was defeated and Caperton awarded $50 million in damages, the coal king proceeded to buy his way through West Virginia's elected Supreme Court of Appeals to overthrow the verdict. According to Leamer, Blankenship gave “more money, by far [$3 million plus], than any other group or individual in any one judicial contest.” The refusal of a corrupt judge to recuse himself was successfully pursued all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, which declared that “a fair trial in a fair tribunal is a fundamental constitutional right.” This, however, was not enough to secure financial redress for Caperton, whose appeals in West Virginia were rejected for a third time in 2009. The vote, his lawyers believed, “was not just a defeat but also an insult and attempt to silence them.” The case proceeded against a background of blackmail, negligence and mining disasters, which eventually combined to precipitate Blankenship's ouster.

An eye-opening story about the relations among politics, business and justice.

Pub Date: May 7th, 2013
ISBN: 978-0-8050-9471-8
Page count: 448pp
Publisher: Times/Henry Holt
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 15th, 2013


NonfictionTHE PRICE OF JUSTICE by Laurence Leamer
by Laurence Leamer
FictionWE NEED TO TALK ABOUT KEVIN by Lionel Shriver
by Lionel Shriver
NonfictionMORTAL SINS by Michael D’Antonio
by Michael D’Antonio
NonfictionAMONG MURDERERS by Sabine Heinlein
by Sabine Heinlein


NonfictionTHE LYNCHING by Laurence Leamer
by Laurence Leamer
NonfictionMADNESS UNDER THE ROYAL PALMS by Laurence Leamer
by Laurence Leamer
NonfictionFANTASTIC by Laurence Leamer
by Laurence Leamer


NonfictionTHE POWER SURGE by Michael Levi
by Michael Levi
NonfictionPUTIN'S KLEPTOCRACY by Karen Dawisha
by Karen Dawisha
NonfictionLICENSED TO LIE by Sidney Powell
by Sidney Powell
NonfictionJUSTICE AND THE ENEMY by William Shawcross
by William Shawcross