THE BOY WHO WOULDN’T SHARE by Mike Reiss

THE BOY WHO WOULDN’T SHARE

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 6 - 8

KIRKUS REVIEW

Even Catrow’s flamboyantly over-the-top art can’t completely rescue this superficial cautionary tale from the heap of mediocre, heavy-handed takes on the theme. Bulbous, sour-faced Edward resolutely guards his heaping pile of toys from little sister Claire (who looks remarkably like Cindy Lou Who in both posture and visage)—“IT’S MINE. MINE. MINE!” Then Mom comes in with a plate of fudge, and so buried is he in the stack that she passes it all to Claire. Edward instantly changes his tune: “ ‘Share my toys,’ said Edward. ‘Take them. / Hold them! Hug them! You can break them!’ ” Edward gets some fudge, and off the two go to play in happy harmony thereafter. Right. Young readers will enjoy picking Edward’s toys, which range from a wizard’s hat and a blow-up, life-size Frankenstein to a “Yeti in a Can,” out of the jumble, but his obviously fudge-driven remorse is entirely too sudden and heartfelt to be credible. Kids will relish the illustrations and get a guffaw or two, though, and that can’t be all bad. (Picture book. 6-8)

Pub Date: June 1st, 2008
ISBN: 978-0-06-059132-8
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: HarperCollins
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2008




MORE BY MIKE REISS

Children JUST TOO CUTE by Mike Reiss
by Mike Reiss
ChildrenMERRY UN-CHRISTMAS by Mike Reiss
by Mike Reiss
ChildrenTHE BOY WHO LOOKED LIKE LINCOLN by Mike Reiss
by Mike Reiss

MORE BY DAVID CATROW

ChildrenDREAM DOG by Lou Berger
by Lou Berger
ChildrenDOZENS OF COUSINS by Shutta Crum
by Shutta Crum
ChildrenTHE FLY FLEW IN by David  Catrow
by David Catrow

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

IndieTHE GIRL WHO LIKED TO WIN by Sunaina Santhiveeran
by Sunaina Santhiveeran
ChildrenMINE! by Shutta Crum
by Shutta Crum