THE ART THIEF by Noah Charney

THE ART THIEF

Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A novel about stolen paintings and forgeries by a student of art crime.

Two paintings—one an altarpiece by Caravaggio, the other a canvas by the Russian Suprematist Kasimir Malevich—go missing, and an eclectic team of detectives and art historians must find them in Charney’s debut. A Cambridge-trained scholar and the founding director of a consulting group on art-crime prevention, Charney is a pioneer in the use of art history to solve art mysteries. He is not, however, a natural storyteller or a gifted writer. The plot is an unwieldy, exasperating mess. There are too many principle characters for any of them to be fully developed, and the ostensibly comic characters—including a fat French inspector who is constantly eating or getting himself wedged into tight spots—are simply embarrassing. The author’s self-conscious attempts to gussy up this flaccid thriller are painfully heavy-handed. There is a surfeit of ugly, unilluminating metaphors—Charney often chooses two or three when one would have been enough. The smattering of French dialogue spoken by his Gallic characters is arbitrary and off-putting, serving to underscore the novel’s general pretentiousness. The book will no doubt earn comparisons to The Da Vinci Code, and such comparisons will be apt, up to a point. Like Dan Brown, Charney presents superficial windbaggery as up-market erudition. But Brown’s hero is a made-up scholar in a fictional field, while Charney is a real-life practitioner and—according to his press materials—genuine innovator in the world in which his novel is set.

A pseudo-intellectual mystery: If this is the best story Charney can build from his experiences, he is advised to keep his day job.

Pub Date: Sept. 18th, 2007
ISBN: 978-1-4165-5030-3
Page count: 304pp
Publisher: Atria
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 15th, 2007




MORE BY NOAH CHARNEY

NonfictionTHE COLLECTOR OF LIVES by Ingrid D. Rowland
by Ingrid D. Rowland
NonfictionSTEALING THE MYSTIC LAMB by Noah Charney
by Noah Charney

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

IndieTHE CURSE OF VAN GOGH by Paul Hoppe
by Paul Hoppe
FictionTHE LAST WEYNFELDT by Martin Suter
by Martin Suter
NonfictionTHE DUKE OF WELLINGTON, KIDNAPPED! by Alan Hirsch
by Alan Hirsch