THE BIG BOOK OF FEMALE DETECTIVES by Otto Penzler

THE BIG BOOK OF FEMALE DETECTIVES

edited by
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Most of the bulked-up anthologies veteran editor Penzler has produced for Black Lizard (The Big Book of Rogues and Villains, 2017, etc.) are remarkable mainly for their comprehensiveness, even their exhaustiveness. Not this one.

Most of the 74 stories Penzler has chosen are beyond cavil. The first 10 entries, originally published between 1864 and 1911, may not set your pulse racing, but they’re historically indispensable, and the tales by L.T. Meade and Robert Eustace, Baroness Emmuska Orczy, and Richard Marsh will set many readers to searching for more stories featuring Florence Cusack, Lady Molly Robertson-Kirk, and Judith Lee. Nor is anyone likely to quarrel with the reprints from the first half of the 20th century, from Carolyn Wells, Anna Katharine Green, Mary Roberts Rinehart, F. Tennyson Jesse, and Mignon G. Eberhart to Phyllis Bentley, Gladys Mitchell, Frederick Nebel, and Richard Sale. H.H. Holmes supplies an adventure of Sister Ursula, Stuart Palmer presents the spinster schoolteacher Hildegarde Withers, and James Yaffe showcases the anonymous mother of the police detective who narrates her armchair-and–coffee table investigations. Trouble arrives only later on, when the field becomes too rich to do more than sample. Following a gap of more than 20 years (1966-1989) that evidently produced no worthwhile short stories featuring female sleuths, Penzler resumes with tales by Marcia Muller, Sue Grafton, Carolyn Hart, Faye Kellerman, Sara Paretsky, Nevada Barr, Linda Barnes, S.J. Rozan, Laura Lippman, Wendy Hornsby, and eight others. But fans will search in vain for anything by such equally eminent candidates as Sharyn McCrumb, Barbara D’Amato, Margaret Maron, Val McDermid, Kathy Reichs, Liza Cody, Denise Mina, Laurie R. King, Rhys Bowen, Karin Slaughter, Kerry Greenwood, or Alan Bradley. The only way for Penzler to have shoehorned them into his 1,100-plus pages would have been to cut the last section, “Bad Girls,” whose dozen selections (including two more by Meade and Eustace and one by Penzler’s adored Joyce Carol Oates) seem to have wandered in from a different collection, or to replace The Secret Adversary, the second-rate 1922 novel in which Agatha Christie introduced the forgettable Tommy and Tuppence, with a short story featuring Miss Marple, who together with Nancy Drew is the most notable no-show here.

On balance, then: lots of landmarks, even more incidental pleasures, and endless provocations for arguments about who really should have made the cut.

Pub Date: Oct. 9th, 2018
ISBN: 978-0-525-43474-0
Page count: 1136pp
Publisher: Vintage Crime/Black Lizard
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2018




MORE BY OTTO PENZLER

MysteryTHE BIG BOOK OF ROGUES AND VILLAINS by Otto Penzler
by Otto Penzler
MysteryBIBLIOMYSTERIES by Otto Penzler
by Otto Penzler

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionWOMEN ON THE CASE by Sara Paretsky
by Sara Paretsky
FictionTHE FOURTH WOMANSLEUTH ANTHOLOGY by Irene Zahava
by Irene Zahava
MysteryCLASSIC AMERICAN CRIME FICTION OF THE 1920S by Leslie S. Klinger
by Leslie S. Klinger