"I KNEW I'D MEET YOU" by Patricia  Lyfoung


From the "Scarlet Rose" series, volume 1
by ; illustrated by & ; translated by
Age Range: 10 - 14
Email this review


Determined to avenge her father’s death, a young girl adopts a vigilante persona.

In a time of swords, full skirts, tricorn hats, and horse-drawn carriages, 18-year-old Maud lives in the quaint French village of Perigord with her beloved father, a blacksmith. When Maud’s father is viciously murdered one night, she vows to head to Paris for vindication and finds herself staying with her estranged, aristocratic grandfather, a man who thinks it best that she become ladylike and marry quickly. Tired of rigid social mores and inspired by a Robin Hood–esque masked man only known as the Fox, Maud decides to become the Scarlet Rose, a do-gooder working under the cloak of darkness (and clad in plunging bodice, very tight breeches, and thigh-high boots). Originally published over a decade ago in French, this quirky graphic import seems to rely on its heavily stylized, full-color, anime-inspired art to overcome narrative incoherence. Lyfoung’s plotting feels like a clunky pastiche of Robin Hood and The Scarlet Pimpernel set against a lavish, evidently all-white pre-revolutionary backdrop. The panels, while small and orderly, are quite busy and crowded, working in unfortunate opposition to the detailed nuance of the time period. Maud embodies a stark dichotomy, quickly shifting from an independent and smart female character to a ditzier one who falls in insta-love and becomes irritatingly clingy. It ends with an unsurprising cliffhanger, but demand for subsequent volumes may be low.

A patchwork conglomeration that does not quite hit its mark. (Graphic adventure. 10-14)

Pub Date: Sept. 5th, 2017
ISBN: 978-1-62991-827-3
Page count: 96pp
Publisher: Papercutz
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1st, 2017


ChildrenTHE BIG BAD FOX by Benjamin Renner
by Benjamin Renner
ChildrenPETER AND THE WOLF by Miguelanxo Prado
by Miguelanxo Prado


ChildrenKNIFE'S EDGE by Hope Larson
by Hope Larson
ChildrenFOILED by Jane Yolen
by Jane Yolen