Email this review


Back on Lewis Island, the quiet Hebrides outpost where he was born (The Lewis Man, 2013, etc.), murder keeps stalking Fin McLeod, late of the Edinburgh CID—this time accompanied by harrowing revelations about his own early years.

Emerging from a shelter where they’ve taken refuge from a passing storm, Fin and his childhood friend Whistler Macaskill realize that a bog burst has drained a nearby loch far enough to reveal the wreckage of a small airplane. From the insignia, they recognize the plane flown by their old friend Roddy Mackenzie, who disappeared 17 years ago. An ill-advised look into the plane’s cabin tells Fin that Roddy’s finally come home. The revelation of his death opens fresh wounds for the members of Amran, the band he’d played for, especially for singer Mairead Morrison, whose lovely image had been the symbol of its runaway success. The discovery means that Fin will have little time to do the job his old friend Kenny John Maclean has hired him for—rid the Red River Estate, which Kenny manages for the Wooldridge family, of the poachers who’ve overrun it—and even less to testify on behalf of the Rev. Donald Murray, the father of Fin’s newly discovered son Fionnlagh’s girlfriend, Donna, and the other grandfather to Donna’s baby, Eilidh. Church elders, unhappy that Donald stalked and shot the gangsters about to execute his wife and daughter, plan to remove him from the ministry of the Crobost Free Church. If only they knew how many other locals were walking around burdened by sins all the heavier for remaining hidden.

May’s poetic descriptions in this final installment of his Lewis trilogy alternate with the loutish behavior of the characters, who are constantly slapping, slugging and coshing each other. The mystery—really, the mysteries—are untidy, but the atmosphere is altogether magical.

Pub Date: Feb. 3rd, 2015
ISBN: 978-1-62365-604-1
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Quercus
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 1st, 2014


MysteryCAST IRON by Peter May
by Peter May
FictionCOFFIN ROAD by Peter May
by Peter May
MysteryENTRY ISLAND by Peter May
by Peter May


FictionA COLD DAY IN PARADISE by Steve Hamilton
by Steve Hamilton
FictionDEAD GIRL WALKING by Christopher Brookmyre
by Christopher Brookmyre
MysteryCRAZY MOUNTAIN KISS by Keith McCafferty
by Keith McCafferty
FictionCOFFIN ROAD by Peter May
by Peter May