WHAT IF…? THEN WE… by Rebecca Kai Dotlich

WHAT IF…? THEN WE…

Short, Very Short, Shorter-than-ever Possibilities
by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Two polar bears and an octopus imagine their way through an Arctic landscape.

“For every WHAT IF, the imagination creates a possibility,” begins this unusual book, “and in that possibility lives a story.” Two polar bears, one with a red-and-blue–striped hat and the other with a walking stick and backpack, rush across an icy isthmus. In the background, a friendly-looking green octopus greets some seals. The two polar bears illustrate each “what if” scenario, looking quizzical or calm, distressed or happy, the octopus a frequent presence in the background. Some of the imagined scenarios make sense or are otherwise evocative for children, such as “What if…the clocks stopped ticktocking? / Then we would have no bedtime.” Others are a bit more puzzling. The conclusion to “What if we shared something amazing and magnificent and wonderful?” is “Then we would keep it our secret, and treasure it every day,” for some reason. And the response to “What if something really big and really scary happened?” is “Then we would whistle and hold hands until… / …it wasn’t as big or as scary,” which may not appropriately address the realities of some children’s lives. The mixed-media illustrations are cute but not particularly enchanting, which largely sums up this inventive but flat story.

Prescribed answers to contrived questions are more likely to stifle imagination than to inspire it. (Picture book. 3-6)

Pub Date: Feb. 12th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-62979-909-4
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Boyds Mills
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 1st, 2018




MORE BY REBECCA KAI DOTLICH

ChildrenYOU AND ME by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
ChildrenALL ABOARD! by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
ChildrenDIGGER THE DINOSAUR by Rebecca Kai Dotlich
by Rebecca Kai Dotlich

MORE BY FRED KOEHLER

ChildrenGARBAGE ISLAND by Fred Koehler
by Fred Koehler
ChildrenFLASHLIGHT NIGHT by Matt Forrest Esenwine
by Matt Forrest Esenwine
ChildrenPUPPY, PUPPY, PUPPY by Julie Sternberg
by Julie Sternberg

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenIDA, ALWAYS by Caron Levis
by Caron Levis
ChildrenFORTUNATELY by Remy Charlip
by Remy Charlip
ChildrenA PERFECTLY MESSED-UP STORY by Patrick McDonnell
by Patrick McDonnell