HER IDEA by Rilla Alexander


by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 6 - 8
Email this review


The author of The Best Book in the World (2014), a paean to reading, brings to the art of writing the same over-the-top exuberance.

Unfortunately, here that enthusiasm trumps not just logic, but even coherence. Ideas—rendered in the dizzyingly bright illustrations as crowds of identical, rubber-limbed homunculi clad only in bathing caps—swarm young Sozi’s mental landscape by the bucketful. Forming a chorus line, they inspire her to “make a work of art.” When she sits down with paper and pencil, though, the ideas wander off or are chased away by an imaginary bear (representing, one supposes, writer’s block). Then a helpful codex with eyes and legs slams shut on a fugitive idea and offers it to Sozi, “squished for safekeeping.” Charmed by this intellectual roadkill, she joins her new friend in a further harvest of tiny fugitives. She then sets down the beginning and middle of a story that ends with a just, if metafictional, twist when the book squishes her so that she can join “her friends” inside. Centering on a smiling, masked child, the two-tone art, along with being hard on the eyes, blandly ignores the violence of the conceptual conceit. Moreover, the narrative suddenly breaks into labored verse after a mostly prose beginning: “But she kept on regardless. She refused to quit. / When THE END came, that’s when she would deal with it!”

A perfect storm of ugly imagery, sloppy thinking and subpar writing. (Picture book. 6-8)

Pub Date: April 14th, 2015
ISBN: 978-1-909263-40-6
Page count: 56pp
Publisher: Flying Eye Books
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 1st, 2015


ChildrenMOTOR MIX by Emily Snape
by Emily Snape
ChildrenTHE BEST BOOK IN THE WORLD by Rilla Alexander
by Rilla Alexander


ChildrenTHE BEST STORY by Eileen Spinelli
by Eileen Spinelli
ChildrenDRAW! by Raúl Colón
by Raúl Colón
ChildrenLIBRARY MOUSE by Daniel Kirk
by Daniel Kirk