WHO? by Robie Harris


A Celebration of Babies
by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 0 - 3
Email this review


This babycentric board book features a diverse cast of characters.

Harris is best known for her matter-of-fact and accurate nonfiction (It’s Perfectly Normal, 1994; Who Has What!, 2011; etc.). Her first board book is equally positive, direct, and charming. Although the cover art shows a brown-skinned girl with two poofy pigtails looking up at the titular question, the first double-page spread answers it with a picture of a blond, white boy: “SWEET BABY! NICE BABY!” Is the promised diversity an illusion? Thankfully, no. The next illustrations are of loving pairs—a dark-skinned baby and his “DADA!” are followed by an Asian “MAMA!” “GRAMMA!” is wearing a hijab. In all, 10 different babies, including a set of twins, are shown. The text on each spread is similar, so young children will quickly join in the refrain: “Who? / Who’s that?” The answer is in bright pink uppercase letters. Each right-hand page repeats “Who’s that?” with “BABY AND…” in pink followed by the declarative, “That’s who!” The final spread echoes the first spread, with all the babies identified as “SWEET BABIES! NICE BABIES!” Rosenberg’s illustrations in a springtime palette against white backgrounds are cheery but not saccharine.

The message that they are “SWEET BABIES! NICE BABIES!” is one that many babies will want to hear again and again. (Board book. 6 mos.-3)

Pub Date: June 5th, 2018
ISBN: 978-1-4197-2834-1
Page count: 20pp
Publisher: abramsappleseed
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2018


ChildrenOLD DOG BABY BABY by Julie Fogliano
by Julie Fogliano
ChildrenAMERICAN BABIES by Global Fund for Children
by The Global Fund for Children
ChildrenGLOBAL BABY BEDTIMES by Global Fund for Children
by Global Fund for Children