ASH & BRAMBLE by Sarah Prineas


Age Range: 12 - 16
Email this review


A girl, a shoe, a clock, a prince: familiar elements are here remixed into a very different “Cinderella.”

Pin awakens in the Godmother’s fortress with no memory, only a silver thimble to give her a clue to her past. Resourceful and determined, soon enough she escapes with Shoe, the fortress’ Shoemaker. Captured again, she awakens again as Pen, a stepdaughter in a town where the prince will hold a ball. Meanwhile, Shoe searches for her and finds that she’s caught in the gears of Story, whose agenda the Godmother seeks to complete. Prineas’ take on “Cinderella” is high-concept but imperfectly executed; the pacing and characterization in particular suffer, largely because the heroine (and plot) are literally rewritten a quarter of the way through (with Pin/Pen less immediately likable in her second, lengthier, iteration). Story as the villain, crafting endings regardless of individual desires, makes storybreaker Shoe the rightful hero here, but Pin/Pen and a love triangle with an inevitable ending take center stage instead, while underdeveloped but fascinating characters from other fractured tales join Shoe in the wings (a lesbian iteration of Rapunzel and a huntsman pining for Snow White among them).

Torn between fairy tale, romance, and almost dystopic rebellion tale, this doesn’t entirely cohere despite the fantastic imagination fueling it; still, flaws notwithstanding, this retelling is not without charm. (Fantasy. 12-16)

Pub Date: Sept. 15th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-06-233794-8
Page count: 464pp
Publisher: HarperTeen
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 15th, 2015


ChildrenROSE & THORN by Sarah Prineas
by Sarah Prineas
ChildrenHOME by Sarah Prineas
by Sarah Prineas
ChildrenMOONKIND by Sarah Prineas
by Sarah Prineas


ChildrenSPINDLE by E.K. Johnston
by E.K. Johnston
ChildrenASH by Malinda Lo
by Malinda Lo
ChildrenENCHANTED by Alethea Kontis
by Alethea Kontis