THE MYSTIC PHYLES by Stephanie Brockway

THE MYSTIC PHYLES

Beasts

KIRKUS REVIEW

Sketchy infodumps and plotting leave fancy packaging to carry the load in this elaborately decorated journal.

Impelled by a request delivered by a cat, 13-year-old orphan Abigail compiles information on 15 probably mythical beasts, from mermaids and sea monsters to bunyips, barguests and Bigfoot. Meanwhile she also records incidents in a largely unhappy life—cloistered at home by a tyrannical grandfather and afflicted at her small-town school by bullies and cliques alike. Framed as a diary that fills every square inch including the endpapers, her narrative is presented on swatches of paper interspersed with a mix of dramatic full-page creature portraits, smaller images of old prints and supplementary drawings. These last are in a more informal style, and all are neatly applied over backgrounds pre-brushed with rich colors. Her “reports” run to only a few short comments or quotes (capped at the end by a stale booklist and a more helpful set of websites). Her personal miseries are abruptly resolved by a miraculous pendant and the revelation—quickly laid out at the end and reading more like a draft scenario—that the mythical creatures are real and there’s a struggle going on between those who would hide them and others who want them exposed.

Thin soup next to Monsterology (2008) and like bestiaries, but a draw for fans of coated paper and stamped covers. (Fantasy. 10-12) 

 

Pub Date: July 1st, 2011
ISBN: 978-1-57091-718-9
Page count: 144pp
Publisher: Charlesbridge
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2011




MORE BY RALPH MASIELLO

ChildrenRALPH MASIELLO'S ROBOT DRAWING BOOK by Ralph Masiello
by Ralph Masiello
ChildrenTHE SKULL ALPHABET BOOK by Jerry Pallotta
by Jerry Pallotta
ChildrenTHE FLAG WE LOVE by Pam Muñoz Ryan
by Pam Muñoz Ryan

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTHE ESSENTIAL WORLDWIDE MONSTER GUIDE by Linda Ashman
by Linda Ashman
ChildrenTHE GRUESOME GUIDE TO WORLD MONSTERS by Judy Sierra
by Judy Sierra
ChildrenHERE THERE BE MONSTERS by H.P. Newquist
by H. P. Newquist