Half-baked, confusing and highly derivative.



From the Extraction series , Vol. 1

Another Hunger Games–wannabe latecomer.

In this toxic Surface settlement, everyone is an under-20 manual laborer (and yet also half of the population receives intensive formal educations that cover chemical formulas and Yates’ correction). The only way to avoid being worked to death or executed (“replaced”) at age 20 is to be picked for Extraction to the planet’s rich, underground Core sector. Every year, the 16-year-olds undergo a mysterious test that measures their Promise. The top scorers in each of the outer sectors (which are work camps established after the Core put down unsuccessful rebellions) are Extracted to the Core. Heroine Clementine is, of course, Extracted, even though this means leaving behind her boyfriend; she vows to find a way to convince those in power that Logan is worthy of a late Extraction. Once in the core, the Extractions undergo training and more testing in order to be assimilated. Clementine so excels that she draws the ire of the Commander’s favorite, a violent bully with a penchant for sexual assault. Unsurprisingly, Clementine discovers that the government running this system has dark secrets. The setting is undeveloped not just logistically and culturally, but also in physical description. Some of the training sequences are cool, though, and the ending sets up a more promising plot for the obligatory second novel.

Half-baked, confusing and highly derivative. (Science fiction. 12-17)

Pub Date: July 22, 2014

ISBN: 978-1-250-04117-3

Page Count: 416

Publisher: St. Martin's Griffin

Review Posted Online: April 30, 2014

Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15, 2014

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet

An emotionally engaging closer that fumbles in its final moments.


From the To All the Boys I've Loved Before series , Vol. 3

Lara Jean prepares for college and a wedding.

Korean-American Lara Jean is finally settled into a nice, complication-free relationship with her white boyfriend, Peter. But things don’t stay simple for long. When college acceptance letters roll in, Peter and Lara Jean discover they’re heading in different directions. As the two discuss the long-distance thing, Lara Jean’s widower father is making a major commitment: marrying the neighbor lady he’s been dating. The whirlwind of a wedding, college visits, prom, and the last few months of senior year provides an excellent backdrop for this final book about Lara Jean. The characters ping from event to event with emotions always at the forefront. Han further develops her cast, pushing them to new maturity and leaving few stones unturned. There’s only one problem here, and it’s what’s always held this series back from true greatness: Peter. Despite Han’s best efforts to flesh out Peter with abandonment issues and a crummy dad, he remains little more than a handsome jock. Frankly, Lara Jean and Peter may have cute teen chemistry, but Han's nuanced characterizations have often helped to subvert typical teen love-story tropes. This knowing subversion is frustratingly absent from the novel's denouement.

An emotionally engaging closer that fumbles in its final moments. (Romance. 14-17)

Pub Date: May 2, 2017

ISBN: 978-1-4814-3048-7

Page Count: 336

Publisher: Simon & Schuster

Review Posted Online: March 29, 2017

Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 15, 2017

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet

A satisfying if slightly lesser sequel. (Romance. 13-17)


From the To All the Boys I've Loved Before series , Vol. 2

Lara Jean's romantic entanglements complicate themselves further.

In the wake of the events detailed in To All the Boys I Loved Before (2014), Lara Jean confesses her love for handsome golden boy Peter. This frees the pair to start a romantic relationship with a clean slate, but over the course of the novel it becomes clear that embarking on a relationship that turns an aggressive blind eye to baggage is never a good idea. When a viral video of a steamy love session between Peter and Lara Jean rears its ugly head and a boy from the past enters Lara Jean's life once more, Lara Jean's life gets complicated. Every character from Han’s adored previous novel is back, with new dimensions given to nearly every one of them. Subplots abound, among them two involving Lara Jean's father and Peter's ex-gal Genevieve, but benefitting most from this second look is John Ambrose McClaren, a boy briefly referenced in the former book who is thrust into the spotlight here as Peter's rival for Lara Jean's heart. With all these characters bouncing around, Han occasionally struggles to keep a steady hand on the novel's primary thrust: Lara Jean’s emotional development. Han gets the job done in the end, but this overeventful sequel pales to the original where structure is concerned. The author's greatest success remains her character work, and the book does indeed give everyone a solid arc, narrative be damned.

A satisfying if slightly lesser sequel. (Romance. 13-17)

Pub Date: May 26, 2015

ISBN: 978-1-4424-2673-3

Page Count: 352

Publisher: Simon & Schuster

Review Posted Online: July 4, 2015

Did you like this book?