LA MADRE GOOSE by Susan Middleton Elya

LA MADRE GOOSE

Nursery Rhymes for Los Niños
Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Elya’s spin on Mother Goose offers a collection of nursery favorites spiced with a Latin American twist.

The most successful of these offerings incorporate Spanish words within the familiar cadences of traditional rhymes. “What are las niñas made of? / Azúcar and flores / And all los colores. / That’s what las niñas are made of!” But most of them bog down in gratingly awkward phrasing resulting from the substitution of two-syllable Spanish words for one-syllable English words—without accommodating meter. Employing “This little cerdo had roasted carne” instead of opting for the more streamlined “This little cerdo had carne” ruins the lyrical integrity of the verse. Other substitutions are unsuccessful on a content front. The transformation of “Sunday’s child” into a bullfighter is disappointing, as is the thieving plate holding a bag of loot (fortuna, to rhyme with luna) in “Hey, Diddle, Diddle.” Both “Old Mother Hubbard” (“Old Madre Rosario”) and “Little Jack Horner” (“Young Juan Ramón”) have been nearly completely rewritten but retain the gists of the originals. Martinez-Neal’s illustrations (made with acrylics, colored pencils, and graphite) abound with multiethnic children sporting the requisite chubby-cheeked features of the toddler set, and the artist’s animals are of the obligatory fuzzy and frolicking kind seen festooning preschool classrooms.

Not one of Elya’s stellar efforts. Such previous offerings as Little Roja Riding Hood (2014) and No More, Por Favor (2010) are far better examples of her snappy language-integration skills. (Picture book. 3-6)

Pub Date: July 19th, 2016
ISBN: 978-0-399-25157-3
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Putnam
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 15th, 2016




MORE BY SUSAN MIDDLETON ELYA

ChildrenLITTLE ROJA RIDING HOOD by Susan Middleton Elya
by Susan Middleton Elya
ChildrenFIRE! FUEGO! BRAVE BOMBEROS by Susan Middleton Elya
by Susan Middleton Elya
ChildrenRUBIA AND THE THREE <i>OSOS</i> by Susan Middleton Elya
by Susan Middleton Elya

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenFLUTTER AND HUM/ALETEO Y ZUMBIDO by Julie Paschkis
by Julie Paschkis
ChildrenDIEZ DEDITOS/TEN LITTLE FINGERS by Jose-Luis Orozco
by Jose-Luis Orozco
Children¡MUU, MOO! by Alma Flor Ada
by Alma Flor Ada