WHAT IF...? by Thierry Lenain


by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 5 - 10
Email this review


“A child sat on his island, looking out at the world and thinking.”

He sees a world full of miseries: war, famine, hegemony, pollution, and sorrow. For each, he imagines a transformation: “What if we lasso the clouds and bring rain to the desert?...What if we wash [the ocean] clean?” In Tallec’s painterly scenes, the child is defined by swift pencil lines, the only color to him his red cheeks and pants—the rest is white. He is placed on negative space, swaths or spots of white that share the spreads with the painted depictions of destruction and evil. It’s a novel visual approach to a familiar theme, subverting what readers may expect by making the reality appear more concrete than the possibility and mostly leaving the what-if’s in readers’ imaginations. Some spreads are at once more pointed and more obscure than others: When the child sees “the powerful gorging, ordering, shouting, and decreeing,” he stands in front of a TV set tuned to a smug-looking politician and thinks, “We have to open their eyes or drive them out.” Open the eyes of the two people watching from the couch? Drive out the powerful? Exactly who those pronouns refer to can spawn a conversation all by itself. At the end, readers learn why the child appears so ephemeral: He doesn’t yet exist but has decided he has the resolve to be born.

Sobering and provocative. (Picture book. 5-10)

Pub Date: April 30th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-59270-281-7
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Enchanted Lion Books
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2019


ChildrenWHAT IS INSIDE THIS BOX? by Drew Daywalt
by Drew Daywalt
ChildrenSEALED WITH A KISS by Beth Ferry
by Beth Ferry
ChildrenJEROME BY HEART by Thomas Scotto
by Thomas Scotto


ChildrenYOU CAN'T BE TOO CAREFUL! by Roger Mello
by Roger Mello
ChildrenI HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE A CHILD by Alain Serres
by Alain Serres
ChildrenA HOUSE THAT ONCE WAS by Julie Fogliano
by Julie Fogliano