RETURN OF A KING by William Dalrymple
Kirkus Star

RETURN OF A KING

The Battle for Afghanistan, 1839-42

KIRKUS REVIEW

An intensively focused study of the ill-begotten launch of the Great Game in Afghanistan. 

Who would gain control of the portal to India: Britain, France, Russia, the Sikhs or the Afghan tribes themselves? And was there really cause for alarm at imperialist advances or a “dysfunctional” intelligence gathering by both the British and Russians? In his exciting, exhaustive study, British historian Dalrymple (The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty: Delhi, 1857, 2007, etc.) sheds light on the enormously convoluted rationale for the First Anglo-Afghan War, ostensibly provoked by Britain in order to reinstall the compliant Shah Shuja ul Mulk (chief of the Sadozai clan) to power in Afghanistan over Dost Mohammad Khan (chief of the Barakzais), who supposedly favored the Russians. In truth, the war exposed the greediness and ignorance of all sides: protecting the interests of the East India Company and catering to the competing ambitions of major players like Sikh ruler Ranjit Singh, Polish agent Ivan Vitkevitch, William Hay Macnaghten and Scottish agent Alexander Burnes. The British garrison was soon outnumbered 10-1 by the rebel forces of Akbar Khan, Dost Mohammad’s able, ferocious son; forced to surrender and retreat in ignominy back to India, the British left Shuja to fall to Dost’s assassins in April 1842 and gained virtually nothing save a more defined border. Dalrymple sagely points out that while the Afghans learned a valuable lesson from this early conflict, namely a firm rejection of foreign rule and a sense of nationalist integrity, the Western powers did not and, indeed, still perpetuate a policy of folly and waste.

A rich excavation of both British and Afghan sources, with gorgeous colored reproductions of Muslim and romantic renderings of the action and characters.

Pub Date: April 16th, 2013
ISBN: 978-0-307-95828-0
Page count: 560pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 2013




BEST BOOKS OF 2013 ON WARS, SOLDIERS AND MILITARY AFFAIRS:

Nonfiction THE GUNS AT LAST LIGHT by Rick Atkinson
by Rick Atkinson
Nonfiction THE BLOOD TELEGRAM by Gary J. Bass
by Gary J. Bass
Nonfiction MONTE CASSINO by Peter Caddick-Adams
by Peter Caddick-Adams
Nonfiction THE SLEEPWALKERS by Christopher  Clark
by Christopher Clark

MORE BY WILLIAM DALRYMPLE

NonfictionNINE LIVES by William Dalrymple
by William Dalrymple
NonfictionWHITE MUGHALS by William Dalrymple
by William Dalrymple
NonfictionFROM THE HOLY MOUNTAIN by William Dalrymple
by William Dalrymple

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionAFGHANISTAN by Tim Bird
by Tim Bird
NonfictionBRITISH MILITARY SPECTACLE by Scott Hughes Myerly
by Scott Hughes Myerly
NonfictionHOLY WAR by Nigel Cliff
by Nigel Cliff