A Story of Power and Persuasion on the Frontier of the Early American Republic
Email this review


 The story of a man's spectacular career in postRevolutionary War New York and his famous son's novelistic effort to rewrite it. The ambitious middle son of a poor Pennsylvania Quaker family, William Cooper (17541809) married in 1774 and used his in-laws' wealth and status to set himself up as a farmer, land speculator, and shopkeeper. But Cooper's real opportunity came in the 1780s, when he bought up the mortgage to a large tract of land near Otsego Lake on the New York frontier. Using tactics of questionable legalityincluding buying out Benjamin Franklin's exiled loyalist son, William, without his knowledgeCooper managed to gain control of the Otsego land and sell it off quickly, simultaneously developing the area and securing his ill-gotten gains. He offered favorable terms to settlers and so earned their trust and loyalty. At the same time, Cooper ingratiated himself with wealthy landowners by managing their land with fantastic success. Cooper became a Federalist political force, and his wealth increased, but his hasty actions often led to disastrous consequences, and in his effort to become a gentleman, he lost touch with the frontiersmen who had made him a success. At his death in 1809which Taylor (History/Univ. of Calif., Davis) persuasively argues was not the result of a blow to the head by a political opponent, as Cooper's biographers have long claimedhe left a shaky domain, the management of which fell largely on the incapable shoulders of his youngest son, James Fenimore. Unable to save his father's empire in actuality, the novelist sought to reclaim it in The Pioneers (1823), a fictional rendering of his father's fantastic life. Good social history, weak literary criticism, but the standout here is William Cooper himself, a true American original. (16 pages illustrations, 7 maps, not seen)

Pub Date: Sept. 26th, 1995
ISBN: 0-394-58054-0
Page count: 688pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 15th, 1995


NonfictionAMERICAN REVOLUTIONS by Alan Taylor
by Alan Taylor
NonfictionTHE INTERNAL ENEMY by Alan Taylor
by Alan Taylor
NonfictionTHE CIVIL WAR OF 1812 by Alan Taylor
by Alan Taylor