YOU DESERVE NOTHING by Alexander Maksik
Kirkus Star


Email this review


A novel that examines the relationship between the public and shared experience of a lively—even magical—classroom, and the private world of a gifted but flawed teacher. 

Largely a character study of Will Silver, master teacher at the International School of France in Paris, the novel advances its narrative through multiple perspectives, much as Faulkner does in As I Lay Dying, one of the texts Will insists his students read. Will is a charismatic English teacher, one of those rare few who inspire a Dead Poets Society–type cult among the seniors in his philosophy and literature seminar. Based on their readings of Sartre, Camus, Faulkner, Shakespeare and Keats, he urges his students to raise questions about the way they live their lives and has them confront their own existential freedom and moral choices. But Will is caught in the irony of his own moral choices when he feels attracted to Marie de Cléry, a student at the school, and begins a torrid sexual relationship with her. Marie is best friends with Ariel, which is to say they have a volatile, love-hate relationship driven both by envy and by jealousy, and it’s clear that Ariel will do anything to pull Will down. While much of the narrative burden of the novel is assumed by Will and Marie, Maksik also provides views of other students, especially Gilad, whose own homoerotic attraction to Will complicates his take on things. Some of the best scenes in the novel involve the reconstruction of the philosophical give-and-take of his classroom, Will’s efforts to get his students to think and to make the literature their own. And despite the administration’s understandable desire to turn Will into a monster who’s preyed upon a vulnerable young woman, he remains sympathetic to the end.

Both intelligent and intellectual, this is both a tribute to brilliant teachers and a cautionary tale of their imperfections.

Pub Date: Sept. 1st, 2011
ISBN: 978-1-60945-048-9
Page count: 336pp
Publisher: Tonga Books
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 1st, 2011


FictionSHELTER IN PLACE by Alexander Maksik
by Alexander Maksik
FictionA MARKER TO MEASURE DRIFT by Alexander Maksik
by Alexander Maksik


FictionGARDEN LAKES by Jaime Clarke
by Jaime Clarke
FictionCLAIR DE LUNE by Jetta Carleton
by Jetta Carleton
IndieFALL SEMESTER by Stephanie Fournet
by Stephanie Fournet