MY OLD PAL, OSCAR by Amy Hest

MY OLD PAL, OSCAR

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 5 - 7
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Alone at the beach, a black-and-white puppy huddles under the pier until it spots a child.

The blond, white child plays alone with the puppy nearby, feigning indifference even while cataloging the puppy’s lack of tags, big feet, “soft puppy beard,” and “big black eyes.” The persistent, perky pup doesn’t accept the child’s emphatic goodbye and gets an earful about the late, beloved Oscar. “You want to be pals. / Well, we can’t be pals. No sir. No way. / Won’t. Ever. Do. That. Again. Ever. / You know who was my pal? Oscar.” Bates’ striking watercolor-and-pencil illustrations let an autumnal spectrum of muted oranges, yellows, and grays flow across the pages. The spray of the waves, the far-off cries of the gulls, and the salted breeze of the sea are expertly evoked in these frames. But the deficit of honest emotion in Hest’s scenes between puppy and child serves to rebuff rather than involve readers. Even the child’s pervading melancholy is communicated in a sterile, forced manner. “The waves were really, really big, and I was really, really sad.” No one will be surprised that the child eventually takes the puppy in, though readers who might have lost dogs themselves will be taken aback that there is no evidence of a search for this puppy’s owner.

Hest and Bates’ previous joint dog project, The Dog Who Belonged to No One (2008), was a more tender and effective narrative. (Picture book. 5-7)

Pub Date: May 3rd, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-4197-1901-1
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Abrams
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15th, 2016




MORE BY AMY HEST

ChildrenARE YOU SURE, MOTHER BEAR? by Amy Hest
by Amy Hest
ChildrenWHEN CHARLEY MET GRAMPA by Amy Hest
by Amy Hest
ChildrenCHARLEY'S FIRST NIGHT by Amy Hest
by Amy Hest
ChildrenLETTERS TO LEO by Amy Hest
by Amy Hest

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

IndieGood Boy, Achilles! by Eddie Ellis
by Eddie Ellis
ChildrenHARRY & HOPPER by Margaret Wild
by Margaret Wild
ChildrenTHE BLUE HOUSE DOG by Deborah Blumenthal
by Deborah Blumenthal