FALSE WITNESS by Andrew Grant


Email this review


The flawed homicide detective Cooper Devereaux returns for a second outing (False Friend, 2017), this time chasing down a quirky killer in Birmingham, Alabama.

Although Lucas Paltrow, a “mysterious mechanic Good Samaritan,” saves the pregnant Deborah Holt’s life by fixing her car, a year later she’s found dead on her 21st birthday, wrapped up like a present. Devereaux and his longtime partner, Tommy Garretty, are assigned to investigate. Soon Siobhan O’Keefe turns up, killed and wrapped in the same way on her 21st birthday. Later there’s a third victim, and the unknown assailant is dubbed the Birthday Killer. It’s a curious plot that gives the impression the author is straining for something new. One suspect is Deborah's boyfriend, the sarcastically described “guitar legend Thor,” aka Oliver Casey, a “twenty-four carat scumbag.” Others include Paltrow and his co-worker Billy Flynn, who has a sealed juvie record. When Flynn’s house explodes and Devereaux wants to save him, Garretty helpfully advises, “Screw Flynn. The odds are he’s a murdering asshole.” The blistering scene that follows is well-done, as are Devereaux and Flynn by the end of it. A couple of subplots help tie the series together. The dying Chris Lambert, a former Police Academy instructor, plots to blackmail Devereaux, who had a checkered childhood and may be “the spawn of a mass murderer.” Or not. And Devereaux's former girlfriend Alexandra is conflicted about getting back together with him, because “she simply wasn’t comfortable in a relationship with the son of a mass murderer.” Meanwhile, whatever might be revealed about his troubled past, Devereaux has become a good adult. It’s hard to see how the author continues with these subplots—Just how bad was Dad? Will Alexandra ever make up her mind?—without letting them get stale.

Overall, a good story with a multilayered hero. The author’s fans won’t be disappointed.

Pub Date: Jan. 2nd, 2018
ISBN: 978-0-399-59433-5
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Ballantine
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 1st, 2017


FictionINVISIBLE by Andrew Grant
by Andrew Grant
FictionFALSE FRIEND by Andrew Grant
by Andrew Grant
FictionFALSE POSITIVE by Andrew Grant
by Andrew Grant


FictionTHE KILLING KIND by Chris Holm
by Chris Holm
FictionCRIMINAL ENTERPRISE by Owen Laukkanen
by Owen Laukkanen
MysteryIT HAPPENS IN THE DARK by Carol O'Connell
by Carol O'Connell