ONE & OTHER NUMBERS WITH ALEXANDER CALDER by Cecily Kaiser

ONE & OTHER NUMBERS WITH ALEXANDER CALDER

Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Using counting as a framework, this book invites viewers to look closely at works by sculptor Alexander Calder.

Calder’s art features prominently, with expansive and clear photographs set against a glossy white background. It’s a lovely, well-curated collection of Calder’s work, including kid-pleasing, colorful mobiles, representational bent-wire sculptures, and solid stabiles, a kind of immobile statuary. Unfortunately, on pages with a relatively high word count, the bold, all-caps type distracts from the delicate art. Written as a direct engagement to readers, this is ostensibly a concept book. However, that intent is lost as it alternates between a simple counting format and convoluted directives. The book works nicely where expectations are clear: “TWO PIECES FLYING HIGH!” Where the text abandons the concept-book formula, however, it leaves readers confused about how to approach the task. When counting balls on a mobile, the answer should ostensibly be “FOUR. BUT WHAT ABOUT THAT TINY RED ONE? OKAY: FIVE!” Frequent narrative interjections, such as “SLOW DOWN!” or “PHEW!” further disrupt the flow. A brief section in which the text is more open-ended, inviting readers to create their own numerical criteria, is more successful. The last page provides a brief Calder biography.

This is a solid visual introduction to Alexander Calder for young art aficionados, but the text fails as a counting book as it strains just a little too hard to be playful. (Board book. 3-6)

Pub Date: Oct. 30th, 2017
ISBN: 978-0-7148-7510-1
Page count: 30pp
Publisher: Phaidon
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 1st, 2018




SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenMORE THAN MEETS THE EYE by Bob Raczka
by Bob Raczka
ChildrenONE RED DOT by David A. Carter
by David A. Carter
ChildrenSANDY’S CIRCUS by Tanya Lee Stone
by Tanya Lee Stone