Kirkus Star


Email this review


Robber baron? Capitalist butcher? Angel? Industrialist-philanthropist Andrew Carnegie has been many things to many people, and in this grand biography, he’s all of them.

Warren Buffett’s recent decision to give most of his $30-billion-plus fortune to charity squares neatly with Carnegie’s view that it is a mark of shame to die with money in the bank; in that matter, but not alone, Nasaw’s overstuffed and very well-written biography is timely and instructive. A poor Scottish immigrant, Carnegie impressed a succession of employers with his skills, intelligence and diligence. He also had a Machiavellian bent, and by the time he was 30, he had built a financial empire based on insider contracts to supply the Pennsylvania Railroad with materials and build iron bridges for it. Carnegie’s Protestant ethics became situational; he hired a substitute in the Civil War and guided money into his own pocket as a civilian advisor to the government. A shrewd investor, he survived economic panics and made out fine in booms, shielded by a strategy of using other people’s money to expand his interests. The darkest side of Carnegie’s character emerged when he and his partners reversed earlier policies of rewarding workers with high wages and benefits, allowing unions to operate freely. Leaving it to lieutenants to manage matters, Carnegie—whose personal fortune probably exceeded Bill Gates’s today—spent more and more time in Europe as labor unrest mounted in the 1880s and ’90s, exemplified by the bloody strike at his Homestead steel plant. Bowed, Carnegie devoted himself to philanthropy, endowing libraries and scientific institutions and pursuing anti-imperialist and pacifist causes, very unlike most of his fellow Republicans—from whom he pointedly split.

A complex man of parts, then, not all of them good. Nasaw (The Chief: The Life of William Randolph Hearst, 2000) does brilliant work in bringing the man to life.

Pub Date: Oct. 24th, 2006
ISBN: 1-59420-104-8
Page count: 851pp
Publisher: Penguin Press
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2006


NonfictionTHE END OF MONEY by David Wolman
by David Wolman
NonfictionTHE BEHAVIOR GAP by Carl Richards
by Carl Richards
NonfictionBORROW by Louis Hyman
by Louis Hyman
NonfictionCURRENCY WARS by James Rickards
by James Rickards


NonfictionTHE PATRIARCH by David Nasaw
by David Nasaw
NonfictionTHE CHIEF by David Nasaw
by David Nasaw
NonfictionGOING OUT by David Nasaw
by David Nasaw


NonfictionMARK TWAIN AND THE COLONEL by Philip McFarland
by Philip McFarland
NonfictionTHE BULLY PULPIT by Doris Kearns Goodwin
by Doris Kearns Goodwin
NonfictionTHE THIN GREEN LINE by Paul Sullivan
by Paul Sullivan
NonfictionTHE TRUE FLAG by Stephen Kinzer
by Stephen Kinzer