THE INVENTION OF SCIENCE by David Wootton
Kirkus Star

THE INVENTION OF SCIENCE

A New History of the Scientific Revolution
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Not exactly a history of science but of our idea of science: a shrewd, thoughtful analysis of how our view of finding truth held steady throughout history and then, over a century, changed and produced the dazzling progress we often take for granted.

Until the 16th century, most people believed that everything worth knowing was already known and that all questions could be answered with deep thought. Aristotle, the ultimate authority in the West, taught that one found truth through logical deductions from incontestable premises. Thus, since the heavens are unchanging and the only permanently unchanging movement is circular, all heavenly movements are circular. According to that worldview, observations are irrelevant. Columbus shattered this concept in 1492; no deduction could have predicted a new continent. Within decades, men—e.g., Copernicus in astronomy and Vesalius in anatomy—were examining phenomena with a new curiosity, claiming their findings were true even if they contradicted the official views of those in power. Many boasted of their achievements. Wootton (History/Univ. of York; Galileo: Watcher of the Skies, 2010, etc.) describes this as “a quite new type of intellectual culture: innovative, combative, competitive, but at the same time obsessed with accuracy.” The author maintains that modern science took form between 1572, when Tycho Brahe saw a nova, or new star, and 1704, when Isaac Newton published Opticks, which demonstrated that white light consists of all colors of the rainbow and that color inheres in light rather than in objects. Except for denouncing modern philosophers who teach that truth is culturally determined, so all explanations of reality are equally valid, Wootton’s account, as massive and sweeping as it is, stops with Newton.

A superbly lucid examination of a dramatic revolution in human thought that deserves a place on the shelf with Thomas Kuhn and David Deutsch.

Pub Date: Dec. 8th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0061759529
Page count: 768pp
Publisher: Harper/HarperCollins
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 15th, 2015




BEST SCIENCE BOOKS OF 2015:

NonfictionRAIN by Cynthia Barnett
by Cynthia Barnett
NonfictionTHE DEATH OF CANCER by Vincent T. DeVita Jr.
by Vincent T. DeVita Jr.
NonfictionGALILEO'S MIDDLE FINGER by Alice Dreger
by Alice Dreger
NonfictionTHE INTIMATE BOND by Brian Fagan
by Brian Fagan

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionINVENTOLOGY by Pagan Kennedy
by Pagan Kennedy
NonfictionCONVERGENCE by Peter Watson
by Peter Watson
NonfictionERUPTION by Steve Olson
by Steve Olson
NonfictionTHE DREAM OF ENLIGHTENMENT by Anthony Gottlieb
by Anthony Gottlieb
NonfictionTO EXPLAIN THE WORLD by Steven Weinberg
by Steven Weinberg