Definitely a work in progress—particularly next to the painterly chaos in David Wiesner’s Art & Max (2010) and Karen...

READ REVIEW

GOODWIN THE GOAT

A never-before-published tidbit from the archives of Corduroy’s creator, featuring a goat that gets into an artist’s paint box.

Freeman’s son Ron mentions in a closing note that his father was unable to get this published despite several revised dummies. It’s easy to see why, as both art and story are a long way from finished. The text features indefinite pronoun antecedents, choppy pacing throughout, and wooden dialogue (“Look what you’ve done! You have ruined my painting and squashed all of my precious water colors!”). It is mechanically laid in below and above quick sketches of figures that often look too small for their frames. Spun from a true incident, the plot is unfocused. After Goodwin makes a mess of plein-air painter Miss Phipps’ work, impoverished farmer Mac Duff attempts to monetize the incident by charging admission to see his paint-spattered goat (which only lasts until it trots off to take a bath). It concludes with Mac Duff and the formerly outraged Miss Phipps euphemistically becoming “friends after that for a long time” and then one day presenting the goat with a nanny. “They” (the goats) too become “good friends,” and “they” (both couples?) go on to live “happily and scrappily ever after.” Both humans are white, as is Goodwin; the nanny is black-and-white.

Definitely a work in progress—particularly next to the painterly chaos in David Wiesner’s Art & Max (2010) and Karen Beaumont and David Catrow’s I Ain’t Gonna Paint No More! (2005). (Picture book. 6-8)

Pub Date: May 16, 2017

ISBN: 978-1-944686-57-4

Page Count: 32

Publisher: Racehorse for Young Readers

Review Posted Online: Feb. 4, 2017

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15, 2017

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet

A lesson that never grows old, enacted with verve by two favorite friends

WAITING IS NOT EASY!

From the Elephant & Piggie series

Gerald the elephant learns a truth familiar to every preschooler—heck, every human: “Waiting is not easy!”

When Piggie cartwheels up to Gerald announcing that she has a surprise for him, Gerald is less than pleased to learn that the “surprise is a surprise.” Gerald pumps Piggie for information (it’s big, it’s pretty, and they can share it), but Piggie holds fast on this basic principle: Gerald will have to wait. Gerald lets out an almighty “GROAN!” Variations on this basic exchange occur throughout the day; Gerald pleads, Piggie insists they must wait; Gerald groans. As the day turns to twilight (signaled by the backgrounds that darken from mauve to gray to charcoal), Gerald gets grumpy. “WE HAVE WASTED THE WHOLE DAY!…And for WHAT!?” Piggie then gestures up to the Milky Way, which an awed Gerald acknowledges “was worth the wait.” Willems relies even more than usual on the slightest of changes in posture, layout and typography, as two waiting figures can’t help but be pretty static. At one point, Piggie assumes the lotus position, infuriating Gerald. Most amusingly, Gerald’s elephantine groans assume weighty physicality in spread-filling speech bubbles that knock Piggie to the ground. And the spectacular, photo-collaged images of the Milky Way that dwarf the two friends makes it clear that it was indeed worth the wait.

A lesson that never grows old, enacted with verve by two favorite friends . (Early reader. 6-8)

Pub Date: Nov. 4, 2014

ISBN: 978-1-4231-9957-1

Page Count: 64

Publisher: Hyperion

Review Posted Online: Nov. 5, 2014

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 15, 2014

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet

Superficially appealing; much less so upon closer examination.

TOO MANY CARROTS

When Rabbit’s unbridled mania for collecting carrots leaves him unable to sleep in his cozy burrow, other animals offer to put him up.

But to Rabbit, their homes are just more storage space for carrots: Tortoise’s overstuffed shell cracks open; the branch breaks beneath Bird’s nest; Squirrel’s tree trunk topples over; and Beaver’s bulging lodge collapses at the first rainstorm. Impelled by guilt and the epiphany that “carrots weren’t for collecting—they were for SHARING!” Rabbit invites his newly homeless friends into his intact, and inexplicably now-roomy, burrow for a crunchy banquet. This could be read (with some effort) as a lightly humorous fable with a happy ending, and Hudson’s depictions of carrot-strewn natural scenes, of Rabbit as a plush bunny, and of the other animals as, at worst, mildly out of sorts support that take. Still, the insistent way Rabbit keeps forcing himself on his friends and the magnitude of the successive disasters may leave even less-reflective readers disturbed. Moreover, as Rabbit is never seen actually eating a carrot, his stockpiling looks a lot like the sort of compulsive hoarding that, in humans, is regarded as a mental illness.

Superficially appealing; much less so upon closer examination. (Picture book. 6-8)

Pub Date: Feb. 11, 2016

ISBN: 978-1-62370-638-8

Page Count: 32

Publisher: Capstone Young Readers

Review Posted Online: Dec. 8, 2015

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 15, 2015

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet
more