THE SEEDS OF LIFE by Edward Dolnick
Kirkus Star


From Aristotle to Da Vinci, from Sharks' Teeth to Frogs' Pants, the Long and Strange Quest to Discover Where Babies Come From
Email this review


A history of the “search for the solution to the sex and conception mystery,” focused on the period between 1650 and 1900.

As former Boston Globe chief science writer Dolnick (The Rush: America's Fevered Quest for Fortune, 1848-1853, 2014, etc.) notes at the beginning of his latest book, “not everyone has wondered why the stars shine or why the earth spins,” but “every person who has ever lived has asked where babies come from.” Thoughtful scientists have confidently delivered the wrong answer, and the author provides a delightful history of what happened until they got it right. Everyone knew that an egg was involved, although brilliant anatomists (Vesalius, William Harvey) searched humans in vain. Semen was essential and—as men were considered the superior sex—the most important factor, but its role remained mysterious. When Antonie van Leeuwenhoek turned his microscope on his semen in the 1670s, he believed that each of the innumerable wiggling creatures contained a tiny human. Most scientists disagreed, insisting that the tiny human resided inside the still-unobserved human egg. This was “preformism.” To early scientists, making an embryo from nothing was absurd. More refined experiments and the discovery that cells make up all living things produced impressive advances, but it was not until 1875 that a German biologist who remains mostly unknown (Oscar Hertwig) first saw a single sperm penetrate an egg (of a sea urchin) and fuse with the nucleus, after which the cell began to divide. Researchers then turned their attention to what happens afterward, but, having effectively answered the big question, Dolnick stops there.

The best sort of science history, explaining not only how great men made great discoveries, but why equally great men, trapped by prejudices and what seemed to be plain common sense, missed what was in front of their noses.

Pub Date: June 6th, 2017
ISBN: 978-0-465-08295-7
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Basic
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 1st, 2017


NonfictionTHE GULF by Jack E. Davis
by Jack E. Davis
NonfictionPRIESTDADDY by Patricia Lockwood
by Patricia Lockwood
NonfictionIMAGINE WANTING ONLY THIS by Kristen Radtke
by Kristen Radtke
NonfictionRAPTOR by James Macdonald Lockhart
by James Macdonald Lockhart
NonfictionI CAN'T BREATHE by Matt Taibbi
by Matt Taibbi


NonfictionTHE RUSH by Edward Dolnick
by Edward Dolnick
NonfictionTHE CLOCKWORK UNIVERSE by Edward Dolnick
by Edward Dolnick
NonfictionTHE FORGER’S SPELL by Edward Dolnick
by Edward Dolnick


NonfictionTHE INVENTION OF SCIENCE by David Wootton
by David Wootton
NonfictionEYE OF THE BEHOLDER by Laura J. Snyder
by Laura J. Snyder
NonfictionTHE OVARY OF EVE by Clara Pinto-Correia
by Clara Pinto-Correia