AMERICA IS NOT THE HEART by Elaine Castillo
Kirkus Star

AMERICA IS NOT THE HEART

Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Castillo’s debut novel presents a portrait of the Filipino diaspora, told through the lens of a single family.

Revolving around Hero de Vera—a former rebel (with the scars to prove it) turned au pair of sorts in Milpitas, California—this is a book about identity but even more about standing up for something larger than oneself. The idea is implicit in that name, Hero, though Castillo pushes against our expectations by bestowing it upon a woman fighting patriarchy. Her employer, after all—her sponsor, really—is her uncle Pol, scion of an influential family. For the most part, Castillo tracks Hero’s experiences in the San Francisco Bay Area, highlighting two sustaining relationships: the first with Roni, her uncle’s school-age daughter, and the second with Rosalyn, with whom she falls in love. The most important relationship in the book, however, is the one she develops with herself. It’s not that Castillo is out to write a novel of transformation; Hero is on a journey, certainly, but it’s hard to say, exactly, that the circumstances of her existence change. And yet, this is the point, or one of them, that this sharply rendered work of fiction seeks to address. “She wasn’t killed…or didn’t kill herself,” the character reflects. “Tragedy could be unsensational.” Unsensational, yes—much like daily life. Castillo is a vivid writer, and she has a real voice: vernacular and fluid, with a take-no-prisoners edge. At the same time, she complicates her narrative by breaking out of it in a variety of places—both by deftly incorporating languages such as Tagalog and Ilocano and through the use of flashback or backstory, in which we learn what happened to Hero before she left the Philippines. There are also two second-person chapters (the rest is told in third-person) that further complicate the point of view. Here, we encounter Pol’s wife, Paz, who untangles the intricate ties of family, and Rosalyn, who explains the vagaries of love. Through it all, we have a sense that what we are reading is part of a larger story that stretches beyond the borders of the book. “As usual,” Castillo writes, “you’re getting ahead of yourself, but there isn’t enough road in the world for how ahead of yourself you need to get.”

Beautifully written, emotionally complex, and deeply moving, Castillo's novel reminds us both that stories may be all we have to save us and also that this may never be enough.

Pub Date: April 3rd, 2018
ISBN: 978-0-7352-2241-0
Page count: 416pp
Publisher: Viking
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2018




11 DEBUTS YOU SHOULD PAY ATTENTION TO :

FictionA LUCKY MAN by Jamel Brinkley
by Jamel Brinkley
FictionTHE PISCES by Melissa Broder
by Melissa Broder
FictionTHE COMEDOWN by Rebekah Frumkin
by Rebekah Frumkin

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

FictionTHE GANGSTER OF LOVE by Jessica Hagedorn
by Jessica Hagedorn
FictionTHE SYMPATHIZER by Viet Thanh Nguyen
by Viet Thanh Nguyen
FictionTHE HOUSE OF BROKEN ANGELS by Luis Alberto Urrea
by Luis Alberto Urrea